United Methodists react to Chauvin verdict

Translate Page

United Methodists across the connection joined the national response to the guilty verdict handed down April 20 in the trial of former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin for the killing of George Floyd.

A jury convicted Chauvin on three counts of murder and manslaughter.

Bishop David Bard, interim episcopal leader of the Minnesota Conference, described the verdict as both a measure of relief and a profound sadness, noting that, “no verdict can return a person from the dead.”

In Minneapolis, the decision was met with both relief and acknowledgement of the significant anti-racism work that remains.

The Rev. Dana Neuhauser, who serves New City Church — a United Methodist church plant in South Minneapolis — was at the site of Floyd’s memorial when the verdict was announced. Most of the people she was with were bracing for an acquittal, she said.

“My initial reaction was shock, then relief,” Neuhauser said. “A Black colleague with whom I was standing said, ‘We matter, we matter, we matter.’”

Meanwhile, the Rev. Laquaan Malachi, who serves North United Methodist Church in North Minneapolis, said he feels like he’s in a limbo of sorts.

“We are celebrating the mediocrity of our justice system,” he explained. “This verdict does not exonerate the system but instead highlights how difficult it makes justice when there are no cameras watching. This verdict was a baby step and we have a long way to go.”

Throughout the past year, both Malachi and Neuhauser have spoken at vigils, marched for justice, protested police brutality against people of color and provided a pastoral presence during the uprising that followed Floyd’s murder. While they are relieved that Chauvin was held accountable for his actions, they acknowledge that the work for an equitable and just world is just beginning.

“From here, we continue ahead,” Malachi said. “This is an important momentary victory, but the work of healing a broken world occurs in our everyday interactions with those around us. The work of the church is to live into this world that we are convinced can be real.” 

“Sometimes it feels like shoveling in the middle of a blizzard and all I’ve got is a teaspoon,” Neuhauser said, “but I’ll keep shoveling.”

The Rev. Ginger Gaines-Cirelli, senior pastor of Foundry United Methodist Church in Washington, D.C., was in Minneapolis and present with the Floyd family as they awaited the verdict.

She described it as “a heavy consequential moment for us as people of faith.”

“This is potentially a real pivot moment to recommit to address how to dismantle these things instead of pretending they’re not real,” she said in a Facebook Live post on Foundry’s page. “I believe God is … always with the oppressed and the suffering.”

Church leaders expressed the sense that the verdict was just while urging the religious community to be involved in ending widespread racism and systemic injustice against people of color.

M. Garlinda Burton, interim top executive of the United Methodist Commission on Religion and Race, noted that the Hebrew word for justice, mishpat, occurs more than 200 times in the Old Testament.

“God has set an anti-racism agenda for us and God expects us to live that out in our relations with Christ and one another,” she said. “It must start with hard conversations and penitent prayer and action, and truth about what the U.S. Christian church community has failed to do and be.”

A portrait of George Floyd by artist Peyton Scott Russell forms part of a memorial to Floyd in Minneapolis. Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted April 20 for murdering Floyd. Photo by Lorie Shaull.
A portrait of George Floyd by artist Peyton Scott Russell forms part of a memorial to Floyd in Minneapolis. Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin was convicted April 20 for murdering Floyd. Photo by Lorie Shaull.

In a statement, the United Methodist Board of Church and Society wrote: “As followers of the Risen Christ, we must name white supremacy as sin, and state that true justice will only be achieved when we reconstruct the public safety systems in each of our communities so that Black, Brown, Indigenous and People of Color receive equitable safety and security.”

The Baltimore-Washington Conference, Black Methodists for Church Renewal and United Methodist Women issued a joint statement calling United Methodists to action, including working for comprehensive police reform and lifting up and practicing the Social Principles and resolutions on racism. They also shared a list of resources for working toward anti-racism.

In the aftermath of the verdict, the United Methodist Council of Bishops released a statement calling for dismantling systemic racism and reminding the church of its biblical mandate to work for justice.

“The racial violence experienced by communities of color has pushed us to think more deeply about how white supremacy functions in our society,” the statement reads. “We are called as people of faith to work for a world in which love, peace and justice reign.” 

Floyd’s May 2020 death was a catalyst that led to the creation of the denomination’s “Dismantling Racism” initiative, launched weeks later.

While relief and even brief exuberance are understandable in the wake of the conviction, United Methodist bishops also urged the church to continue the hard work of racial reconciliation. 

“We need the Holy Spirit, the breath of Jesus for the continuing work of dismantling racial inequity … the work of building Beloved Community, the work of love,” Bard wrote.

Added Bishop Grant J. Hagiya of the California-Pacific Conference: “This verdict represents the basement and not the ceiling of what needs to take place in our nation.”

The verdict shows the community was able to hold law enforcement officers accountable, but abuses still go unpunished, said Bishop Laurie Haller of the Iowa and Dakotas conferences.

“The list of Black lives who have been needlessly killed grows each day,” she said. “The pervasive culture of racism and white supremacy, increasingly incited by political rhetoric, grows each day. The fear among parents of Black children grows each day. The flaunting of our laws against racial profiling and discrimination grows each day.”

Bishop Peggy A. Johnson of the Eastern Pennsylvania Conference suggested that, “we shed some silent tears along with our many brothers and sisters who have been traumatized by racism, unjust systems and brutality.”

“Many people have not received justice in the past, and racial inequity and violence against people of color has been a painful reality,” she said.

Bishop Sudarshana Devadhar of the New England Conference said the Chauvin conviction “provides a measure of justice for George Floyd and that ray of hope for all who’ve been waiting for accountability.”

More work needs to be done around racial issues, he said, adding that “justice is not complete until all children of God can live together in community, with mutual respect and dignity and equity.”

Chauvin and his family also are suffering, several bishops acknowledged, and are worthy of the prayers of United Methodists along with Floyd’s family.

There are “no winners in the George Floyd murder case,” said Bishop Frank J. Beard of the Illinois Great Rivers Conference. “We are all hurt and weakened by all forms of injustice and pain. I pray for Derek Chauvin and for his family. I continue to pray for the family of George Floyd. I pray for our police officers and those sworn to protect and to serve.”

Bishop LaTrelle Easterling of the Baltimore-Washington Conference offered a similar message.

“This is a time of prayer for the Floyd family as they continue to mourn,” she said. “This is also a time of prayer for the Chauvin family as they, too, are suffering. As the people of God, we know that forgiveness is available to all who seek it with earnest hearts.”

Gaines-Cirelli of Foundry also encouraged prayer for the members of the jury.

“Not everyone will be supportive of their decision” and may respond to them negatively, she said. “Let’s surround them with prayer.”

The Rev. Kevin R. Murriel, senior pastor of 7,000-member Cascade United Methodist Church in Atlanta, led an online discussion soon after the verdict with his predominantly African American congregation.

He spoke of feeling relief at the verdict, especially because of past disappointments when police were absolved in killings of unarmed Black people. He also urged his congregation to stay engaged.

“We need to be working more toward justice because today it’s George Floyd, but tomorrow it’s Daunte Wright, and tomorrow it’s all the others who have gone unnamed who we still have to fight for,” Murriel said. 

Other United Methodist organizations and partners also commented on the verdict.

The Rev. Michael L. Bowie Jr., national executive director for Strengthening the Black Church for the 21st Century, described it as being “like Jesus breathed on our nation,” but he noted that hours later, a Black teenage girl was shot by police in Columbus, Ohio.

“Until police reform and the systemic racism in this country is dismantled, we unfortunately will continue to live with the fear of not being able to breathe,” Bowie said.

The Rev. Reuben Eckels, domestic policy advocate at Church World Service, said the verdict has the potential to be a pivotal moment in the history of racial justice in America.

“One verdict does not change an entire system or culture, but it provides a sense of accountability that we as a nation must endeavor to reproduce if we are to ever truly achieve racial justice.”

The Rev. Keith Boyette, president of the Wesleyan Covenant Association, said, “Our system of justice was permitted to work and the jury carefully weighed the evidence and arrived at a verdict consistent with the law. We respect the jury’s verdict.”

United Methodist Women top executive Harriett Jane Olson said, “As people of faith, we celebrate even as we continue our advocacy work. May justice roll down like waters, today and in days to come.”

This story was compiled and reported by UM News reporters Joey Butler, Heather Hahn, Sam Hodges and Jim Patterson. Contact them at 615-742-5470 or [email protected]. Minnesota Conference Director of Communications Christa Meland also contributed to this report.

To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Social Concerns
Pamela Coleman, chair of the history committee at Sharp Street Memorial United Methodist Church, speaks to visitors from the Social Justice Pilgrimage about the joys and struggles of the historic church in west Baltimore. The once bustling “Mother Church of African American Methodism” now hosts about 20 worshippers on Sundays. Photo by Vernon Jordan, UM News.

A whirlwind pilgrimage through Methodist history

Race, social justice and the role of the church in politics all played a role in the first Social Justice Pilgrimage, a day of visiting and learning about United Methodist-associated locales in Baltimore and Washington.
General Church
Council of Bishops President Bishop Thomas J. Bickerton addresses a joint meeting of the Connectional Table and the General Council of Finance and Administration board on May 18 in Nashville, Tenn. He said United Methodist bishops want to join in the conversation of how to reduce the number of U.S. bishops strategically without damaging the church’s mission. Photo by Heather Hahn, UM News.

As church exits rise, proposed budget drops

In the wake of projected losses from church closures and disaffiliations, The United Methodist Church’s finance agency continues to shrink the proposed budget heading to General Conference.
Human Rights
The Itchy Dog Singers opened a peaceful rally with a drum circle at the state Capitol in Harrisburg on May 1. Members of the Lenape Nation of Pennsylvania gathered to remind legislators that it is time to give them legal status as a recognized tribe. Photo courtesy of the Eastern Pennsylvania Conference.

United Methodists join rally to recognize indigenous tribe

On May 1, members of the Lenape Nation of Pennsylvania gathered for a peaceful rally on the steps of the state Capitol in Harrisburg. They were there to ask legislators to give them legal status as a recognized tribe.


United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2023 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved