Commissions, UMW adapt to new budget realities

Translate Page

From developing new revenue sources to sharing office space, the 13 general agencies that serve The United Methodist Church continue to look for creative ways to adapt to denominational budget cuts made worse by the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

Ten general agencies rely on apportionments — shares of church giving — for their funding.

The General Council on Finance and Administration board is proposing a 2021-2024 general church budget with the bottom line of about $413.4 million — about a 31% decrease from the previous four years. The budget includes bishops and other denomination-wide ministries beyond agencies. Ultimately, General Conference — now postponed to Aug. 29-Sept. 7 — sets the general church budget.

Despite the uncertainty, agency leaders plan to carry out their missions and ministries.

“In every time of great challenge is also a time of great opportunity and responsibility to make a difference,” said Harriett Jane Olson, top executive of United Methodist Women.

This is the second of two stories, covering the five commissions and United Methodist Women and how they plan to move forward. Commissions are bodies created by General Conference to carry out assigned functions for an indefinite time period. The first story featured the other seven agencies.

A historic image of a Methodist circuit rider. The United Methodist Commission on Archives and History serves as the church's “ministry of memory” to learn from the past and anticipate the future. Image courtesy of the General Commission on Archives and History at Drew University. 
A historic image of a Methodist circuit rider. The United Methodist Commission on Archives and History serves as the church's “ministry of memory” to learn from the past and anticipate the future. Image courtesy of the General Commission on Archives and History at Drew University.

Archives and History

The United Methodist Commission on Archives and History is looking to develop new revenue streams, including foundation grants and increased donations from individuals and families, said Ashley Boggan Dreff, the top executive there.

“We are beginning the process of reaching out to fellow institutions and archives to work together to protect and utilize our common Wesleyan DNA to ensure our stories are preserved,” Boggan Dreff said.

Archives and History gathers, preserves and disseminates materials on the history of The United Methodist Church and its antecedents.

Two senior staffers, the Rev. Alfred Day III and L. Dale Patterson, retired in 2020. One part-time worker was promoted to full time and additional responsibilities were incorporated into a new job description for the top executive position, filled by Boggan Dreff. The staff now has four full-time workers and one part-time employee.

Some grants and research awards not supported by a specified endowment fund have been eliminated, as have training sessions for archivists. Also, the capacity for archiving digital files is not able to be expanded at present and the library’s reading room is closed.

“The staff feels very stretched having to do more work with less resources,” Boggan Dreff said. “The prolonged uncertainty of how we will look post-General Conference and the delays also adds a layer of anxiety for security of work.”

Nevertheless, Archives and History remains dedicated to its mission.

“We will continue to do the work of helping United Methodists understand our collected past to envision the futures of Methodism,” Boggan Dreff said. “Even with our restricted budgets, we hope to increase our programmatic efforts to mark the historic times we are living in and ensure that we are inclusive in our historic narrative, and maintain a historic lens as we gaze upon the future.”

United Methodist Communications

United Methodist Communications is developing a strategy for the next five years to reflect the largest proposed budget cut to any agency over the next four years — 35%.

“UMCom has maintained its current ministry and service offerings through 2021, after restructuring and changes in recent years,” said Dan Krause, chief executive. “We anticipate reducing the ministries we offer over the next several years and will have more details as the plan is finalized this spring.”

United Methodist Communications, which increases the awareness and visibility of the denomination and includes United Methodist News, is budgeted to spend $7.4 million of its cash reserves in 2021.

The agency has reduced its staff by 18% since October 2019. There were 82 employees at the end of January, down from 100 at the end of 2019. The departures have been “driven almost entirely by voluntary departures caused by either uncertainty in the church or changes to upcoming retirement benefits imposed by the United Methodist Council on Finance and Administration,” Krause said.

Because of the changes, United Methodist Communications made an offer to employees who might choose to leave while certain benefits could be grandfathered into their retirement package.

“UMCom seeks to continue supporting the communication needs of The United Methodist Church into the future, recognizing that communication is at the core of the Gospel and church,” Krause said.

A woman holds a sign during an April 4, 2018, peace and unity rally. The rally followed the United Methodist Commission on Religion and Race’s participation in the United to End Racism Prayer Walk in Washington. File photo courtesy of the Commission on Religion and Race. 

A woman holds a sign during an April 4, 2018, peace and unity rally. The rally followed the United Methodist Commission on Religion and Race’s participation in the United to End Racism Prayer Walk in Washington. File photo courtesy of the Commission on Religion and Race.

Religion and Race

Annual conferences, seminaries, districts and congregations are now charged for use of some resources from the United Methodist Commission on Religion and Race, one way the agency is making up for budget cuts.

Religion and Race is dedicated to the naming, confronting, repenting and dismantling of institutional racism.

“We are more selective about sending staff to do in-person training or coaching on dismantling racism,” said M. Garlinda Burton, the interim top executive.

“During the pandemic, we have saved money by conducting our board meetings and training via Zoom, which has saved us on travel and lodging costs. We are adapting.”

The agency is also using short-term contractors to ease the workload, although “the staff is working much more,” Burton said.

Since January 2020, Religion and Race has cut three positions. It now has seven employees.

“We have a dedicated staff,” she said. “At the same time, fatigue and ‘survivors’ guilt’ — after seeing colleagues lose their jobs — have been inevitable. I am encouraging staff members to use their vacation and renewal time as much as possible.”

Status and Role of Women

The agency that champions the inclusion of women in The United Methodist Church now has a smaller office space in Chicago and is leaving unresolved for the time being whether to replace a staff person who left last year for another job.

Read part one

Faced with an on-going pandemic and denominational uncertainty, United Methodist general agencies are reducing staff while staying true to their missions.

Read "General agencies cutting back"

“We reached a work-share agreement with the Northern Illinois Annual Conference and are thrilled to be moving into a much smaller set of offices within our same location (The Chicago Temple) and to be sharing the cost of equipment and services with our United Methodist Church neighbors,” said Dawn Wiggins Hare, top executive of the United Methodist Commission on the Status and Role of Women.

The commission has five employees after the departure of Elaine Moy. She began work Jan. 25 as the senior director for development, finance and institutional equity at Religion and Race.

The coronavirus pandemic saved the agency money in 2020 because there was less travel and no in-person trainings, Hare said.

“We have worked to provide quality resources and trainings to The United Methodist Church consistent with our mandates and mission during this transitional period,” she said.

United Methodist Men

United Methodist Men is seeking to tap a new funding source.

“Our staff are finding (that) some men and women whose major link with us is Scouting ministries have not always been included in our funding efforts,” said Gilbert C. Hanke, the top executive for United Methodist Men. “Additional work in that area is being expanded immediately.”

United Methodist Men coordinates men’s ministry efforts. It is responsible for raising 75% of its own budget, with 25% coming from the World Service Fund, one of seven apportioned funds of The United Methodist Church. That funding decreased by 30% last year.

“There will be some cost reductions in the next 12 months with projected retirements,” Hanke said. “We continue to work on our working-from-home procedures and for some staff, working from home may continue for some time. We do expect to have a blended mix of persons who mostly work from home and some who mostly work from the office after vaccinations are available.” 

United Methodist Women

United Methodist Women has developed a strategic plan that is helping the 150-year-old organization remain flexible during the economic uncertainty faced by the denomination.

Harriett Jane Olson, top executive, said despite the challenges right now, God is calling United Methodist Women to focus on the needs of women, children, youth and marginalized communities.

The agency does not receive funding through apportionments. United Methodist Women members have made generous contributions to enable special grants to National Mission Institutions, addressing needs in local communities around the country, Olson said.

The organization has had two retirements, but no involuntary terminations have been made, she said. Those two positions will not be filled.

Olson said the organization keeps “a close eye on our expenses.”

“During this time, we are continuing to implement a previously developed strategic plan that streamlines the organization to make it nimbler to enable us to respond to emerging needs of members and the communities we seek to serve.” 

Patterson and Gilbert are UM News reporters in Nashville, Tennessee. Contact Patterson at 615-742-5470 or [email protected] To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at

Sign up for our newsletter!

General Agencies
Dawn Wiggins Hare (right), top executive of the United Methodist Commission on the Status and Role of Women, becomes emotional as she and Harriett Jane Olson, United Methodist Women (now United Women in Faith) chief executive officer, lament the failure of two amendments to the church's constitution focused on equality in the church for women and girls during the United Methodist Women Assembly 2018 in Columbus, Ohio. The Commission on the Status and Role of Women is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year. File photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Women’s commission at 50, still a long way to go

The top executive of the agency advocating for women’s equality in the church reflects on how far they’ve come and what work still remains.
General Agencies
Cynthia Bond Hopson leads a meditation for General Council on Finance and Administration board members and guests during a worship service at the Upper Room Chapel in Nashville, Tenn. Hopson called on the finance agency to be bold in a time of uncertainty. “Tomorrow is uncertain,” she said. “Today is all we have.” She serves as chief equity officer and assistant general secretary of the United Methodist Board of Higher Education and Ministry. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Amid church exits, work starts on record-low budget

United Methodist leaders agree that big changes are coming as the denomination grapples with rising church disaffiliations. But disagreements remain on how best to balance financial uncertainty with missional commitments.
General Church
A graphic depicts how giving flows from local churches to annual conferences to the denomination-wide ministries of the global United Methodist Church. In a time of mounting church disaffiliations, the denomination’s financial leaders are trying to develop a church-wide budget that keeps in mind needs at all levels of the denomination. Graphic courtesy of the Connectional Table.

Debate looming on how low budget should go

The two bodies that develop The United Methodist Church’s budget agree cuts are needed, but disagreements are brewing over stewardship in a time of mounting church disaffiliations.