New budget must wait for General Conference

Translate Page

General Conference is the only body that can set denominational budget and apportionment guidelines for The United Methodist Church.

That legal requirement, found in Paragraph 806 of the Book of Discipline, applies even when extraordinary circumstances — like a pandemic — delay a planned meeting of the top legislative body, the United Methodist Judicial Council has ruled.

In Decision 1409, released on March 25, the council said the 2017-2020 budget adopted in 2016 remains in effect and that a new base percentage proposed by the General Council on Finance and Administration “cannot be used for calculating 2021 apportionments without prior authorization.”

“Absent General Conference action, the 2017-2020 budget, including approved apportionment formulas, continues to be legally binding and operative until replaced by a new quadrennial budget,” the decision stated.

A year ago, the pandemic-forced postponement of General Conference left the finance agency’s board grappling with the need to set 2021 apportionments, the requested shares of giving from conferences, before an apportionment formula had been established for the 2021-2024 general church budget.

At that time, the majority of board members decided they had no choice but to extend into 2021 the apportionment calculations approved by the 2016 General Conference. The board also decided at its March 27, 2020, meeting to consult with the Judicial Council.

Received on July 14, 2020, the GCFA petition asked the Judicial Council for a declaratory decision on four questions related to the legality of certain actions. The petition was added to the court’s postponed April 2020 meeting docket.

Judicial Council currently is deliberating on the 19-item docket during its first virtual session since the coronavirus pandemic began.

The Rev. Kabamba Kiboko, Judicial Council secretary, said Decision 1409 was being released before the docket’s completion because of the annual conferences’ approaching deadlines for submission of legislation, including proposed budgets and the apportionment formulas referenced in the decision.

The church’s constitution gives General Conference full legislative power to “determine and provide for raising and distributing funds necessary to carry on the work of the Church,” Decision 1409 pointed out.

“Pursuant to this authority, the General Conference enacted comprehensive legislation circumscribing the rights and duties of the GCFA but also establishing a process for setting quadrennial budgets and apportionment formulas,” the decision continued.

Language in the disciplinary provisions “makes abundantly clear” that all recommendations submitted by GCFA must be approved by the General Conference and the finance agency “cannot act contrary to approved budgets, apportionment formulas, and directives without prior authorization,” the decision said.

In its ruling, the Judicial Council acknowledged the pandemic’s economic impact on church funds and the understandable reasons why GCFA would propose a different base percentage for calculating 2021 apportionments. Still, the finance agency “cannot proceed in the manner proposed without authorization by the General Conference.”

While GCFA is using the same apportionment calculations approved by the 2016 General Conference, most apportionment-supported ministries have downsized their budgets over concerns about the financial effects of both the pandemic and now-delayed decisions related to the future of the denomination.

Last November — when the finance agency board unanimously approved 2021 spending plans for agencies and other ministries supported by general-church apportionments — almost all were based on a 50% apportionment collection.

Other items on the docket of the Judicial Council’s current virtual session also relate to the effects of a delayed General Conference. On March 22, the court released Memorandum 1408, which clarifies a 2019 ruling related to the administrative process for clergy and the right of a clergy person to fair and due process.

Both 1408 and 1409 relate to issues that the United Methodist Council of Bishops had placed on a 12-item agenda when it called for a special virtual General Conference on May 8. The bishops have now decided to cancel that call and will instead use their regularly scheduled April meeting to discuss results of listening sessions and discern a possible new timeline.

Bloom is assistant news editor emeritus for United Methodist News.

News media contact: [email protected]. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

UMNEWS-SUBSCRIPTION
General Agencies
Cynthia Bond Hopson leads a meditation for General Council on Finance and Administration board members and guests during a worship service at the Upper Room Chapel in Nashville, Tenn. Hopson called on the finance agency to be bold in a time of uncertainty. “Tomorrow is uncertain,” she said. “Today is all we have.” She serves as chief equity officer and assistant general secretary of the United Methodist Board of Higher Education and Ministry. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Amid church exits, work starts on record-low budget

United Methodist leaders agree that big changes are coming as the denomination grapples with rising church disaffiliations. But disagreements remain on how best to balance financial uncertainty with missional commitments.
General Church
A graphic depicts how giving flows from local churches to annual conferences to the denomination-wide ministries of the global United Methodist Church. In a time of mounting church disaffiliations, the denomination’s financial leaders are trying to develop a church-wide budget that keeps in mind needs at all levels of the denomination. Graphic courtesy of the Connectional Table.

Debate looming on how low budget should go

The two bodies that develop The United Methodist Church’s budget agree cuts are needed, but disagreements are brewing over stewardship in a time of mounting church disaffiliations.
Judicial Council
Bishop Minerva Carcaño speaks about The United Methodist Church's social witness during the 2020 Pre-General Conference Briefing in Nashville, Tenn. The bishop has been suspended with pay since March. In a memorandum released Oct. 26, the Judicial Council declined to take up the bishop’s case at this stage of the complaint process. File photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Church court declines to take up bishop’s case

Bishop Minerva Carcaño has been suspended from episcopal duties since March. While not naming the bishop, The United Methodist Church’s top court ruled that it did not have jurisdiction to take up a complaint against a bishop at this stage of the judicial process.