Estimating financial impact of church exits

Other Manual Translations: 한국어 Português Español

Over the past year, United Methodist financial leaders have faced the conundrum of trying to figure out what a potential church split means for the denomination’s bottom line.

General Conference, the denomination’s top lawmaking assembly, faces multiple proposals to resolve the church’s longtime debate over LGBTQ inclusion by splitting the denomination. The big question mark: How many congregations would leave the denomination if General Conference approves a formal separation

While there is still no definitive answer, the General Council on Finance and Administration board got an idea of where to begin its calculations during its Nov. 19 online meeting.

Based on a survey of the 54 U.S. conferences, the finance agency now estimates the denomination stands to lose about 20% of U.S. local church net expenditures between 2021 and 2024. Forty-seven conferences responded to the agency’s survey.

What about bishops?

The General Council on Finance and Administration board also discussed the recommendation from the Council of Bishops that no new U.S. bishops be elected until 2024.

Even before COVID-19 began its deadly spread, GCFA warned the bishops that without some changes, the Episcopal Fund that supports their work would run out of money in the next four years.
 
The agency, which administers the fund, has been dipping into reserves to cover bishop costs — using about $7 million to $8 million since 2017. By the end of this year, the agency projects that the Episcopal Fund will have $12 million to $13 million in reserves.
 
“Where we are at this point, if GCFA says to a jurisdiction that this is the number of bishops that you can have, there is no enforcement mechanism for that,” said North Texas Conference Bishop Michael McKee, the GCFA board president.
 
The bishops said they would work with the five jurisdictions, the bodies that handles U.S. bishop elections, to get them on board with no new bishop elections.

The options for reducing bishops include merging episcopal areas or having retired bishops serve in interim roles. When that happens, the Episcopal Fund pays the difference between the retired bishop’s pension amount and a bishop’s current salary level.

Ultimately, General Conference determines the funding and thus the number of United Methodist bishops.

For the time being, the GCFA board approved a 2021 Episcopal Fund spending plan that assumes a 65% apportion-collection rate and keeps the current 66 bishops’ housing allowance, office allowance and salaries at the same levels as 2020. 

Read GCFA press release
The survey results do not mean conferences are forecasting that 20% of U.S. United Methodist churches will depart or close during the next four years. Net expenditures can vary widely by congregation.
 
What the results do mean is that the agency expects church departures and closures to result in a 20% decline in one of the key factors in determining the budget for denomination-wide ministries.
 
GCFA requests apportionments — shares of church giving — from each U.S. conference based on a formula that includes its local church spending, local church costs, the economic strength of the conference and a base percentage approved by General Conference.
 
The agency board is asking the coming General Conference to drop the economic-strength part of the formula and substantially reduce the base percentage

That still leaves church net expenditures as an important factor in determining apportionments. GCFA defines net expenditures as what a church spends after capital expenses, apportionments and benevolent giving.
 
The agency multiplies a conference’s total local church net expenditures by the General Conference-approved base percentage to determine that conference’s apportionments.

At this point, GCFA is projecting that a 20% decline in net expenditures will result in about $41 million less in requested apportionments by 2024.
 
Because local-church spending varies from year to year, GCFA always uses data from earlier years. For example, the agency calculated the apportionments requested in 2020 using local-church expenditures from 2017.

“For churches that we know have left at the end of the year, we would take them out of the equation for the apportionments for the following year,” Rick King, the agency’s chief financial officer, told the board.
 
“So at the end of 2021, any churches that have left will be deducted from the apportionments for 2022.”

The giving in the U.S. also helps determine the apportionments GCFA requests from central conferences, church regions in Europe, Africa and the Philippines. U.S. apportionments provide 99% of the funding for denomination-wide ministries such as general agencies and bishops.

Planning for the next four-year budget remains ongoing. The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in the postponement of General Conference from May this year to Aug. 29-Sept. 7, 2021. The GCFA board plans to take up budget adjustments at least twice before the postponed General Conference.

For the time being, the board unanimously approved 2021 spending plans for agencies and other ministries supported by general-church apportionments.
 
Almost all are based on a 50% apportionment collection rate — not only because of expected church departures but also because of the still-untold toll of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

“This is a plan that in a year of uncertainty is meant to be conservative because we don’t know what is going to happen,” King told the board.
 
GCFA recommended that agencies and other ministries use the dramatically reduced collection rates in developing their spending plans. 

Still, the Rev. Moses Kumar, the agency’s top executive, emphasized that the agencies' spending plans had already won their respective boards’ approval before the Nov. 19 meeting.
  
“We didn’t choose it for them,” Kumar said. “We recommended it.”

If more money comes in, King said, the additional funds will be distributed to ministries by the proportions determined by General Conference. 

“GCFA’s real responsibility here is to make sure agencies do not spend money they don’t have,” King said. 

The Rev. Steve Court, GCFA board member from the East Ohio Conference, said he prayerfully accepted the process but urged his fellow board members to keep in mind that the reduced budgets would mean “significant” staff reductions.

“Most of agency costs relate to staffing,” Court said. “I am aware that this is a 2021 plan, not a 2020 plan, so we have a year for the implementation to take place.”

Ministries across the denomination are already facing financial strain.
  
As of the end of October, U.S. apportionment receipts were down $11.6 million compared with the same time last year. At this point, GCFA is projecting a 70% collection rate for 2020 — significantly lower than during the worst of the 2008-2010 global recession.

“We have two things colliding at the same time,” said North Texas Conference Bishop Michael McKee, the GCFA board president. “We still don’t know the impact of the pandemic and whatever happens next year at General Conference.”

Hahn is a multimedia news reporter for United Methodist News. Contact her at (615) 742-5470 or [email protected]. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

UMNEWS-SUBSCRIPTION
Mission and Ministry
Farmers harvest rice in Pujehun, southern Sierra Leone in January. The farm is part of the Bishop Yambasu Agriculture Initiative, named in honor of late Bishop John K. Yambasu. During its virtual spring meeting, the United Methodist Board of Global Ministries approved $3.5 million to support the program’s agricultural projects. File photo by Phileas Jusu, UM News.

More church support for African agriculture

During a virtual meeting of United Methodist Global Ministries, church leaders voted to continue supporting the Bishop Yambasu Agricultural Initiative and other long-term priorities, such as global health, disaster response and migrant workers.
General Church
A praise team from Central Korean United Methodist Church in Dallas leads hymns and songs during the first in-person gathering of the Association of Korean Churches in The United Methodist Church. Photo by the Rev. Thomas Kim, UM News.

Association of Korean Churches discerns its uncertain future

In the first in-person annual gathering of the Association of Korean Churches in The United Methodist Church, several panelists questioned whether the church’s membership decline could be attributed to a lack of spiritual renewal and its long-standing conflict over homosexuality.
Church Leadership
The Rev. Angela Cooley Bulhof hugs Caton Darling during a visit to his home in Lake Charles, La., to check on the progress of repairs following Hurricane Laura in 2020. Bulhof, pastor of University United Methodist Church in Lake Charles, says Louisiana has been pounded by seven hurricanes and two tropical storms since August 2020. File photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Stress, burnout afflicting pastors

The daily life of United Methodist pastors is getting more and more stressful, with COVID-19, racial unrest, natural disasters and a likely denominational split over sexuality taking a toll.