Task force to investigate GC2019 voting

Translate Page

General Conference organizers have appointed a task force to investigate possible improper voting at the recently completed special session of The United Methodist Church’s top lawmaking body.

The multinational Commission on the General Conference held an emergency meeting by teleconference March 16, after a preliminary review found that “a very limited number” of ineligible people potentially obtained credentials to vote. The commission has not reported a precise number.

The group named 12 of its members to serve on the task force, and authorized staff members Sara Hotchkiss, business manager, and the Rev. Gary Graves, secretary, to negotiate with auditing firms to help with the work.

“The task force of commission members was created to work with the secretary and business manager of the General Conference to address matters related to credentialing, voting and other systemic issues of the 2019 special session,” Kim Simpson, the commission’s secretary, announced at the meeting’s conclusion.

Most of the two-hour meeting took place in closed session to allow members to engage in negotiations, discuss personnel and consult with an accountant. All three activities are listed as exceptions to the denomination’s open-meetings rules. For meeting participants, the teleconference started as early as 6 a.m. and as late as 9 p.m. depending on their location around the globe.

Graves said the task force expects to report its findings to the full commission before the group’s next regularly scheduled meeting in the fall. But the date for that meeting has yet to be set.

The commission held the meeting after Graves revealed March 14 the possibility that people who were correctly denied delegate credentials later were able to procure them.

The revelation of potential voting irregularities follows a highly contentious General Conference in which more than 800 delegates aimed to set the denomination’s direction in its longtime debate over homosexuality.

Who is on the task force?

The task force members are:

Duncan McMillan, commission chair; the Rev. Mujinga Kashala, commission vice chair; Kim Simpson, secretary; Stephanie Henry, Rules Committee chair; the Rev. Juliet Spencer, Education and Innovation Committee chair, the Rev. Lynn Hill, Program Committee chair; Bishop Thomas Bickerton of the New York Conference; Bishop Rodolfo Juan of the Davao Area in the Philippines; and the Rev. Gary George, the Rev. Joseph Ndala Mulongo, Christine Flick and Marie Kuch-Stanovsky.

By 438-384, voters adopted the Traditional Plan, which reinforces the denomination’s bans on same-sex weddings and “self-avowed practicing” gay clergy and adds enforcement measures.

Graves told United Methodist News Service that the number of possible ineligible voters was too slim to affect the final outcome of support for the Traditional Plan or the defeat of the rival One Church Plan. The latter would have left questions of marriage up to individual clergy and churches, and ordination up to annual conferences.

However, voters later decided by a two-vote margin, 402-400, to substitute a minority report for Petition 90066, disaffiliation legislation that would allow churches, within limitations, to leave the denomination while keeping church property.

Because voting is by secret ballot, Graves said, General Conference organizers do not know if the possible ineligible voters supported a particular outcome.

Denials and charges are already flying even before the task force begins its work.

The sons of two different bishops, East Congo Area Bishop Gabriel Unda and South Congo Area Bishop Kasap Owan, were named in a New York Times article as possible ineligible voters.

Both bishops and their sons contend that the two men were duly elected reserve delegates. Each of the denomination’s regional units, called annual conferences, elects a certain number of delegates to General Conference. A conference can elect as many reserves as they choose.

Bishop Unda issued a statement on March 17 recounting a conversation with Graves during the February 2018 Council of Bishops’ meeting, in which Graves advised him to organize the election of reserve delegates to the special 2019 General Conference. Unda said reserves were elected during the annual conference meeting in July 2018 and that his son, Germain Unda Mupasa, was elected as a reserve.

Unda Mupasa also said that he voted as a reserve delegate. He is listed on General Conference attendance records as a reserve East Congo delegate, and is listed in the Feb. 25 Daily Christian Advocate as an East Congo reserve delegate, although he was not named in earlier published lists. The Daily Christian Advocate is the official record of General Conference. He is not listed in the East Congo Conference Journal from 2018, but the conference provided UMNS with a copy of a certificate of election with Unda Mupasa's name.

The same New York Times article also named Philippe Kasap Kachez, son of Bishop Kasap, as a possible ineligible voter.

Bishop Kasap provided to United Methodist News Service a list of elected delegates and reserves that he said General Conference officials had before the Feb. 23-26 meeting started in St. Louis. His list of delegates elected in 2018 shows his son as the seventh “replacement reserve” delegate. Kasap Kachez is not listed on General Conference delegate attendance records

The annual conferences list delegates and reserves and the order of election in their conference journals, which are provided to the General Council on Finance and Administration, the denomination’s finance agency. The agency does not have the journal of the 2018 South Congo Conference meeting, but Bishop Kasap provided it to United Methodist News Service and the journal does show Kasap Kachez being elected as a reserve delegate.

When the New York Annual Conference met in special session on March 16, the General Conference 2019 delegation from New York issued a call to the denomination in response to the voting irregularities.

During a presentation about General Conference 2019, the New York delegates demanded “an immediate determination by all governing committees of the General Conference that the taint caused by voting irregularities has so impacted the legislative activity and the integrity of the General Conference that allowing any actions to stand would be unjust and immoral.” Their call drew applause from the audience.

Both the Traditional Plan and disaffiliation legislation face a review in April by the Judicial Council, the denomination’s top court. The requests for constitutional review came before the issue of ineligible voters became public.

The court had earlier identified constitutional problems in both the Traditional Plan and the original version of Petition 90066

General Conference, the only body that officially speaks for the entire United Methodist Church, typically meets every four years. Its next gathering will be in Minneapolis in 2020.

Hahn is a multimedia news reporter for United Methodist News Service and Brown is UMNS news editor. Contact them at (615) 742-5470 or [email protected]. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

General Church
The opening day of the special session of the 2019 General Conference of The United Methodist Church.  An investigation into voting irregularities at the denomination’s top lawmaking assembly is underway. Photo by Kathleen Barry, UMNS.

GC2019 voting credentials under review

After an in-depth review, it’s possible “a very limited number” of ineligible people obtained credentials to vote.
General Church
Bishops process into worship on Feb. 24, 2019, at the special session of the General Conference of The United Methodist Church, held in St. Louis, Missouri. Photo by Paul Jeffrey, UMNS

Denials, charges fly in GC2019 voting credentials review

One delegate named as a possible ineligible voter contends he was a duly elected reserve, but he is not listed on General Conference attendance records.
General Conference
Delegates and bishops join in prayer at the front of the stage before a key vote on church policies about homosexuality during the 2019 United Methodist General Conference in St. Louis. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

GC2019 maps uncertain way forward

More than 53 percent of General Conference delegates approved the Traditional Plan, but how much of the plan will take effect is unknown.