Filipino pastors fear for safety

Other Manual Translations: español
The Rev. Joel Q. Bengbeng (center), superintendent of the Ilocos South District in the Northwest Philippines, is among the United Methodist pastors from the Baguio Episcopal Area who say they have experienced harassment due to their social justice work. Photo courtesy of the Rev. Hinivuu Pecaat.
The Rev. Joel Q. Bengbeng (center), superintendent of the Ilocos South District in the Northwest Philippines, is among the United Methodist pastors from the Baguio Episcopal Area who say they have experienced harassment due to their social justice work. Photo courtesy of the Rev. Hinivuu Pecaat.
Amid a strict home quarantine on the island of Luzon, two United Methodist pastors said they fear for their safety because of harassment and intimidation — and because of COVID-19.

The Rev. Joel Q. Bengbeng, superintendent of the Ilocos South District in the Northwest Philippines, part of the Baguio Episcopal Area, said officers of the Philippine Army have harassed him due to his social justice work.
“I fear for my life. I persist not to go out by myself. I seek help from a relative to accompany me or drive for me,” Bengbeng said.

Candon City, where Bengbeng lives, is under the enhanced community quarantine due to the spread of COVID-19. As of April 2, there were more than 2,600 confirmed cases in the country and 96 deaths.
Bengbeng told UM News by phone that he has found the combination of threats to be a heavy predicament.

“I have two unseen viruses, COVID-19 and the threat to me, which really makes me feel unsafe.”

On March 4, military men visited Bengbeng at Candon City United Methodist Church in Ilocos Sur, accusing him of a connection with the Communist Party of the Philippines-New People's Army, the reformed communist party.

The men told Bengbeng that a document was recovered that listed him as a staff member for the Ilocos Human Rights Alliance, which the officers claim is connected to the New People’s Army.
Bengbeng denies the allegation. He said that his advocacy for social justice is part of his work as a pastor and his mandate as United Methodist clergy.

The men urged Bengbeng to sign a document surrendering, which he refused to do.
“I regard this intimidation as an attack not only against me but The United Methodist Church as well. It is meant to silence the prophetic voice of the church, to distract us from discharging our sacred duty to uphold justice, especially in these trying times,” he said.

Bengbeng said he suspects the surveillance might be due to his participation in a movement opposing the construction of a dam in Salcedo, Ilocos Sur, which threatened to displace families.
The Rev. Brian Asuit of San Pedro United Methodist Church in Santa Cruz, Ilocos Sur, said he also experienced harassment and intimidation.
He was visited by soldiers in May of 2019 at his previous church, Bucao United Methodist Church in Tagudin. Soldiers came several times last year at his current church assignment, San Pedro United Methodist Church in Santa Cruz. 

In March, officers returned several times. They asked Asuit to sign a prepared statement and take an oath of allegiance while the military took his picture, according to a statement issued by The Philippines Board of Church and Society.

“It is indeed a predicament. My biggest fear is not only for myself but for my family and my church members as well who are so anxious of the military presence,” Asuit said.

“As a pastor, it is the mandate of my faith to decry any form of violence; it is biblical and it is stipulated in the Social Principles of The United Methodist Church. It is not only for me, but for all.”

The Rev. Genesis Antonio, a United Methodist clergy who serves as chairperson of the Philippines Board of Church and Society, spoke out against the harassment.

“Intimidation as an attempt to hinder God's work is of the devil (and) it should be denounced,” he said.
“I enjoin all United Methodists to be one in denouncing all forces that impede God's mission here on earth. We should be one in pursuing God's agenda and united despite all the challenges, including harassment and intimidation,” Antonio said.

Subscribe to our

Like what you're reading and want to see more? Sign up for our free daily and weekly digests of important news and events in the life of The United Methodist Church.

Keep me informed!

The Philippines Board of Church and Society’s March 16 statement condemned the treatment of United Methodist clergy.

“We strongly protest, reject and condemn the surveillance and intimidation of pastors, as well as having our church members sign, under duress, ‘confessions’ as members of armed dissident groups, and ‘surrendering’ to government forces.”
Bengbeng said the visits from the military men, which began in May of 2019, made him uncomfortable and caused anxiety for his elderly mother who lives with him.

“Every time they came to visit, they would always take pictures with me,” he said.
He asked them not to return, reiterating that the claims against him were false and unfounded.
Since that first visit, he said he has feared for his safety. The military visits also are affecting his work as a pastor and district superintendent.

Bishop Ciriaco Q. Francisco of the Manila Area, who is assigned to the Church and Society board, also decried the harassment.

“We denounce intimidation and harassment against people who are advocating for human rights and justice because they are peaceful, loving people and law-abiding citizens. If they support those who are crying for justice, that is part of our prophetic ministry.”

The bishop had a message for the clergy. 

“Don't be afraid; be strong. Let us stand together in solidarity with the poor, the needy and the oppressed.”

The Rev. Aniceto R. Villalon Jr., executive director of the Philippines Board of Church and Society, prayed for strength for those being treated unfairly.

“I can only pray that God may please give them the strength that they will need to be able to come out victorious from the most difficult ordeal they go through,” he said.

Bishop Pedro M. Torio Jr. of the Baguio Episcopal Area explained why there is a need to denounce intimidation and harassment.

“Provided that there is no truth to allegations against us, we will oppose all forms of intimidation and harassment. These actions violate our dignity and rights as human beings. Intimidation and harassment threaten the integrity and intensity of our Christian witness.

“Our Christian engagement in the face of socio-economic, political and even religious injustice is our concrete experience of God's incarnating love in the midst of suffering and pain. This is our calling.”

Torio conveyed his message to all clergy who put their lives at risk for prophetic ministries.

“Courage of conviction must be demonstrated with courtesy of communication. Fearless views must be rooted in balanced perspectives. We must articulate our Christian position while reaching out to minister to all people, including and especially those whose actions we question. And while being one-sided prevents us from willingly listening to those we disagree with, let us remind ourselves that it is always our responsibility to hear them out and listen to their side of the story.”

Despite his fears, Bengbeng said he and his peers will continue to live out their vows.

“We will continue to follow the way of Christ who challenged the powerful. We will persist to live out our baptismal vows to reject evil and injustice. We will strive to fulfill our ordination vows to seek justice, peace and freedom for all people.”

Mangiduyos is a communicator from the Philippines. 

News media contact: Vicki Brown at (615) 742-5470 or [email protected]. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Social Concerns
The Rev. Gilbert Caldwell, a retired United Methodist pastor and civil rights activist who marched alongside the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., speaks during a Black Lives Matter rally June 7 in Willingboro, N.J. To Caldwell’s right is his wife, Grace Caldwell. To Caldwell’s left is the Rev. Vanessa Wilson, chairperson of the Greater New Jersey Commission on Race and Religion and pastor of Good Shepherd United Methodist Church in Willingboro. The protest was one of many taking place in the U.S. in smaller cities and towns involving United Methodists. Photo by Aaron Wilson Watson.

Smaller communities affected by protests

United Methodists have been involved in Black Lives Matter rallies in small towns and midsize cities.
Mission and Ministry
Dozens gather for the burial of the Rev. Themba Siwela of Gutu Mupandawana Circuit Masvingo District. Many did not wear face masks or maintain social distancing. Photo by Kudzai Chingwe, UM News.

Close ties challenge rural Africa COVID-19 fight

Close relationships in rural Africa make social and physical distancing to avoid COVID-19 culturally difficult.
Global Health
The Rev. Michelle Wilson offers sack lunches from the door of the church van as part of the Hands of Hope food security program at Gordon Memorial United Methodist Church in Nashville, Tenn. The church received a Sheltering in Love grant from the United Methodist Committee on Relief that has enabled it to expand existing food security ministries with seniors and persons experiencing homelessness during the COVID-19 pandemic. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

In trying times, churches extend their reach

Grants from the United Methodist Committee on Relief allow churches to expand programs, increase capacity during pandemic.