Support UM News on World Press Freedom Day: Give to help sustain and expand the storytelling capacity of UM News. Your donation today will transform information into inspiration and ensure we can continue sharing stories of God’s work in the world through The UMC. Help us reach our $10,000 goal and keep this vital ministry fair, faithful, trusted and free for all!

Effort to reimagine Discipline moves forward

Key points:

  • United Methodist leaders are evaluating what portions of the Book of Discipline apply worldwide and what can be adapted in the church’s different geographic regions.
  • At this point, the central conferences in Africa, Europe and the Philippines have the authority to adapt parts of the Discipline to their missional context.
  • A constitutional-amendment package, called regionalization, would extend the same authority to the U.S.
  • The work on the Discipline overhaul is not dependent on regionalization. But if regionalization is not ratified, what is deemed adaptable will still apply to the U.S. church.

United Methodist leaders from four continents are moving forward with a years-long effort to restructure the denomination’s main policy book.

They want to make clear what parts of the Book of Discipline are essentials that bind all United Methodists together and what parts can be adapted in the church’s different geographic regions.

For the longest time, this project has only involved determining what is adaptable in the denomination’s central conferences — eight church regions in Africa, Europe and the Philippines that each consist of multiple bodies called annual conferences. Under the denomination’s constitution, central conferences long have held the right to make “such changes and adaptations” to the Discipline’s administrative section as missional needs and differing legal contexts require.

Now, regionalization — a package of constitutional amendments up for a vote in annual conferences this year — potentially adds a new wrinkle to the work. Under regionalization, the central conferences and the church in the U.S. would each become regional conferences with the same authority to adapt the Discipline.

To be ratified, at least two-thirds of the total voters at this year’s annual conferences will need to support the measure. Bishops expect to announce the voting results in early November.

But regardless of whether regionalization is ratified, the work will continue to create a more globally relevant policy book — what leaders are calling a General Book of Discipline.

“It helps us to better understand the worldwide nature of the church,” Germany’s Bishop Harald Rückert said. “So even if the structures cannot follow at this point — because ratification fails — the thinking has changed to be a worldwide connection.”

Rückert is the chair of the 2025-28 Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters, which spent much of its organizing meeting Jan. 26-29 focused on reinvigorating its work on the Discipline overhaul. The meeting took place at the headquarters of the United Methodist Board of Global Ministries in Atlanta.

Ultimately, Rückert and other church leaders hope United Methodists ratify regionalization — which the standing committee developed alongside the Connectional Table and a grassroots group called the Christmas Covenant.

They also hope the 2028 General Conference will approve the standing committee’s recommendations for the General Book of Discipline. Without regionalization, the portions deemed adaptable will still apply in the United States.

The Rev. Nelly W. Wright, a new standing committee member from Liberia, said she felt blessed to be part of the discussion.

“People from all around the world are part of this group,” she said. “They have different understandings, different educational backgrounds, different cultural backgrounds. We are gathered together to come up with decisions that will lead our church.”

Members of the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters join for a group photo at the United Methodist Board of Global Ministries headquarters in Atlanta. Photo by Adam Bowers, Global Ministries.
Members of the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters join for a group photo at the United Methodist Board of Global Ministries headquarters in Atlanta. Photo by Adam Bowers, Global Ministries.

How the project began

General Conference, the denomination’s top lawmaking body, in 2012 assigned the standing committee to identify what in the Discipline truly applies around the globe. The committee is the only denomination-wide body where a majority of members live outside the U.S.

Committee begins theological work

The United Methodist Church’s Committee on Faith and Order met alongside the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters. The Faith and Order Committee, whose members include United Methodist scholars and ecumenical leaders, is responsible for guiding the denomination in informed theological reflection and discernment. It also is helping the standing committee in developing a General Book of Discipline that includes the essentials for the denomination. Photo by Heather Hahn, UM News. 

The United Methodist Committee on Faith and Order is one of the bodies helping to develop the General Book of Discipline. The committee is responsible for guiding the denomination in informed theological reflection and discernment.

The committee, whose members include United Methodist scholars and ecumenical leaders from around the globe, has additional tasks assigned by last year’s General Conference. The group met together immediately before the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters’ meeting in Atlanta to do its work.

Read more

The goal is to make the policy book — and United Methodist Church governance in general — less U.S.-centric.

Since 2012, the standing committee has been working with members of other denominational leadership bodies to comb through the Discipline. Both in 2016 and last year, the standing committee provided drafts to General Conference delegates and sought feedback from annual conferences across the connection.  

Last year’s General Conference gave the mandate for the effort to continue. The legislative assembly also gave the standing committee permission to propose changes to the Discipline’s language where needed for more global resonance.

Retired Bishop Patrick Streiff, who was the standing committee’s chair when the work began, told the church leaders meeting in Atlanta that their job is to decide what in the Discipline deals with matters that are “distinctively connectional.”

“General Conference has the authority on everything that is distinctively connectional,” he said. “But what does that mean? Is it the whole book that General Conference edits? Really? Or is there a way that some of these things are adaptable in different regions?”

Determining what is really connectional and applicable worldwide, he said, will require “a lot of listening to each other and our different cultures and situations.”

Streiff’s hope is that the work will result in a General Book of Discipline that is much slimmer and easier to understand and translate than what The United Methodist Church has now. He also hopes the new Discipline will contain fewer redundancies and repeated requirements using the word “shall.”

“It will create a covenant of who we want to be together instead of all these detailed rules and innumerable ‘shalls,’” he told those gathered in Atlanta.

Members of the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters join in opening worship in the sanctuary shared by the United Methodist Board of Global Ministries and Cascade United Methodist Church’s Midtown campus in Atlanta. The standing committee, a permanent committee of General Conference, met Jan. 26-29 in Atlanta to begin its work for the next four years. Photo by Heather Hahn, UM News.
Members of the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters join in opening worship in the sanctuary shared by the United Methodist Board of Global Ministries and Cascade United Methodist Church’s Midtown campus in Atlanta. The standing committee, a permanent committee of General Conference, met Jan. 26-29 in Atlanta to begin its work for the next four years. Photo by Heather Hahn, UM News.

What’s under discussion

General Conference already has determined that certain parts of the Discipline absolutely are not adaptable. Changing these provisions requires at least General Conference action and possibly annual conference action, too.

The nonadaptable parts, listed in the Discipline’s Paragraph 101, are:

  • The Constitution
  • Doctrinal Standards and Our Theological Task
  • The Ministry of All Christians
  • The Social Principles.

Altogether, that makes the first 147 pages of the new 2020/2024 Discipline non-adaptable.

That still leaves the Book of Discipline’s Part VI, Organization and Administration. At 663 pages, Part VI is the biggest section in the denomination’s policy book.

To decide what’s adaptable, the standing committee has worked with three other denominational leadership bodies — the Committee on Faith and Order, the Ministry Study Commission and the Connectional Table.

Much of what the leaders are doing is going through Part VI’s paragraphs one by one to see what can be adapted in local contexts. Whatever they deem adaptable, they propose moving to a new Part VII in the Book of Discipline. This new part of the Discipline would still be required in the United States should regionalization not be ratified.

But if regionalization is ratified, Rückert suggested the standing committee might ask General Conference not to include the new Part VII in the Discipline. Instead, the Part VII would become simply a blueprint for regional conferences’ own Regional Books of Discipline.

“The question of whether or not the adaptable portions that we identify will be part of a global Book of Discipline or not, we can decide a little bit later,” Rückert told the standing committee. “The work still is very important.”

A new committee

Even if regionalization does not pass, last year’s General Conference approved a change in how the church deals with matters that relate solely to the U.S.

Subscribe to our
e-newsletter

Like what you're reading and want to see more? Sign up for our free UM News Digests featuring important news and events in the life of The United Methodist Church.

Keep me informed!

The Discipline’s new Paragraph 507 details a new United States Regional Committee, which will act as a legislative committee during General Conference reviewing all petitions that pertain to the U.S. The committee will consist of all U.S. delegates elected to General Conference as well as a lay and clergy member from each central conference.

Its authority will be similar to that of the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters, which also acts as a legislative committee during General Conference reviewing all petitions related to the central conferences.

Just as with the standing committee, anything the new U.S. Regional Committee supports will have to go before the full international General Conference plenary for approval.

“Without the ratification of regionalization, the U.S. will still depend on General Conference,” Rückert told United Methodist News. “They have to go through General Conference for everything, and I don’t think that they really want that.”

If a new U.S. Regional Conference is established with ratification, the U.S. Regional Committee will cease to exist.

Whatever happens, Dr. Glenn Paraso is among the United Methodists excited to see where work on a new more global Discipline goes. Paraso is a lay member of the standing committee and chief executive of the Mary Johnston Hospital in the Philippines.

“It’s like defining a new path in order to govern better,” he told UM News. “Hopefully, if we consider context and culture, because of our diversity, then maybe we can live into our ministries more. The U.S. will be the U.S. The Philippines will be the Philippines. And Africa will be Africa. So maybe our diversity will make us unite better.”

Hahn is assistant news editor for UM News. Contact her at (615) 742-5470 or [email protected]. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free UM News Digest.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Faith Stories
The Rev. Dr. Richard Huskey died one day after being ordained an elder in full connection in The United Methodist Church. He is pictured at left upon his seminary graduation in 1974. At center, Huskey attends a 1977 rally to support an ordinance that banned discrimination in employment and housing in St. Paul, Minn. He had selected the photo to represent his time in ministry. At right is Huskey in 2014. Photos are courtesy of Huskey; the 2014 photo is via the LGBTQ Religious Archives Network.

LGBTQ activist ordained on deathbed

In an emotional finish worthy of Hollywood, the Rev. Dr. Rick Huskey was ordained on his deathbed after waiting since the 1970s for The United Methodist Church to allow the ordination of openly gay people.
Judicial Council
Members of the 2024-2028 Judicial Council are (front row, from left) the Rev. Jonathan Ulanday; the Rev. Susan Henry-Crowe, president; the Rev. Angela Brown, secretary; and Molly Hlekani Mwayera; (back row, from left) Bill Waddell; Andrew Vorbrich; the Rev. Øyvind Helliesen; the Rev. Luan-Vu Tran; and Harriett Olson. The Judicial Council publicly released a decision on June 3 related to the Mississippi Conference’s process for allowing congregations to leave with property. Photo by Linda Bloom, UM News.

Ruling: Stop alternative church-exit plans

The United Methodist Church’s top court strikes down the Mississippi Conference’s process to let churches leave with property after the denomination’s disaffiliation policy expired.
General Conference
The Rev. Gabriel Banga Mususwa. Photo courtesy of the author.

An appeal to hold General Conference outside US

The United Methodist Church’s top assembly has never met in the central conferences; the decision to hold the 2028 gathering in Minneapolis should be rescinded.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2025 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved