United Methodists speak out in wake of synagogue shooting

It will not do for United Methodists to expect God to step in to bring about change after a deadly shooting that killed 11 and wounded six at a Pittsburgh synagogue, said the Pittsburgh Area United Methodist bishop.

“As you pray, I urge you not to suggest to God what you want God to do to bring about change,” said Bishop Cynthia Moore-Koikoi said in a statement. “But rather, I urge you to listen to God so that God can reveal to you what to say and what to do in order to provide comfort to our Jewish sisters and brothers, the first responders and all those for whom this tragedy reignites previous trauma.”

The shooting Oct. 27 at Tree of Life Congregation Synagogue in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood was allegedly the work of 46-year-old Robert Bowers, who was wounded and is charged with 29 federal counts and 11 state charges in the attack, reported NBC News.

The attack is likely the deadliest attack on the Jewish community in the history of the United States, according to the Anti-Defamation League. The victims ranged in age from 54- to 97-years old.

“These killings should serve to remind all of us to work to eradicate antisemitism,” said Jim Winkler, president and general secretary of the National Council of Churches. “This tragedy takes place in the broader context in our nation of a resurgence of gun violence and white supremacy. Our struggle for justice and peace takes place across numerous fronts.”

The United Methodist Women issued a statement linking the shooting to other societal ills.

“At a time of rising vitriol, racism, hate and violence in the world born of deep economic crisis and global shifts, it is time for the church to speak out,” said the statement. “If we do not, God will be appalled. We feel compelled to raise a prophetic voice challenging the climate of distrust, distortion of truth and fear, shifting the conversation to our common future.”

Thousands join an outdoor vigil in Pittsburgh for victims of the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue. Photo by the Rev. Dawn Hand.
Thousands join an outdoor vigil in Pittsburgh for victims of the shooting at the Tree of Life synagogue. Photo by the Rev. Dawn Hand.

Closer to home, a United Methodist professor at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary said he was familiar with Tree of Life Synagogue, which had very positive relations with the seminary.

“First of all, we need to make very, very, very clear that hatred and violence to the Jewish community is in no way acceptable to the church,” said Steve Tuell, the James A. Kelso Professor of Hebrew and Old Testament. “There certainly is no excuse for thinking in terms of us versus them. There is simply us.”

More than a thousand people turned out for a Oct. 27 vigil to honor the victims that was organized by students at Pittsburgh's Allderdice High School, near the scene of the massacre, the Western Pennsylvania Conference reported. An interfaith prayer service was held at nearby at Sixth Presbyterian Church.  

United Methodist clergy and lay leaders in the Pittsburgh District immediately reached out to the rabbis and synagogues to determine how they might be supportive, Moore-Koikoi said.

Sewickley United Methodist Church in Sewickley, Pennsylvania, held an interfaith service Oct. 28 to mourn the synagogue attack. A rose for each victim was displayed in the sanctuary.

“It was an emotional event,” said the Rev. Russell Shuluga, pastor of Sewickley. “It was a very somber environment and many tears were shed. It was necessary to come together to find comfort with each other and God.”

The Rev. Olav Fykse Tveit, top executive of the World Council of Churches, sent the council’s “condolences to the families, the synagogue and the city of Pittsburgh for the shocking violence and loss of life.

“We are conscious of both the short-term trauma and long-term grief this situation poses to you,” said Tveit in a statement. “Antisemitism is a sin against God and humanity … and this attack upon a Jewish community in a place of prayer and during a moment of celebration of their religious identity is an appalling violation of our shared humanity.

The ecumenical officer for the United Methodist Council of Bishops wrote to the Tree of Life congregation with a “heavy heart,” and quoted 1 Peter 3. “Our holy Scriptures tell us to ‘have unity of spirit, sympathy, love for one another, a tender heart and a humble mind,’” said Bishop B. Michael Watson. 

“We are very aware we very often fall short of that calling,” Watson said  “We want to be better than we are, and we long for a world of peace and unity.  We join our prayers with yours for that kind of shared future.”

Bishop Moore-Koikoi urged United Methodists to focus on the immediate needs of those affected by the shooting, but said later, the church will need to turn to other issues.

“Later, our prayers should turn to what God is calling us to do to help ensure that persons of all faith traditions feel sanctuary in their places of worship. Later, our prayers should turn to what God is calling us to do to help stop hatred of all kinds. Later, our prayers should turn to what God is calling us to do to stop weapons of mass destruction being used to murder innocent people. But for today, and for the next few days, let us focus on the immediate needs of those impacted by the gunman who chose to drive to the Tree of Life Synagogue and open fire.”

Patterson is a United Methodist News Service reporter in Nashville, Tennessee. Jackie Campbell, communications director of The Western Pennsylvania Conference, contributed to this story. Contact Patterson at 615-742-5470 or [email protected]. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

Sign up for our newsletter!

General Church
United Methodist Bishops Tracy S. Malone (left) LaTrelle Easterling (center) and Gregory V. Palmer take part in a panel discussion on major structural changes being proposed to General Conference and the views of black United Methodist leaders during the Black Methodists for Church Renewal meeting in Kansas City, Mo. Photo by John W. Coleman.

BMCR focuses on separation plans, leadership views

The African American caucus of The United Methodist Church endorsed the protocol plan for amicable separation of the denomination.
Mission and Ministry
Art from the book “By and By: Charles Albert Tindley, The Father of Gospel Music,” written by Carole Boston Weatherford and illustrated by Bryan Collier. The story page includes the text, “I still heard spirituals of long ago, Remembered how they moved me so. Hardships woven into hymns I wrote — Every lyric, every note.” Image courtesy of Simon & Shuster.

Spotlighting black heroes in children’s books

A new children’s book tells the story of Methodist minister Charles A. Tindley, who worked his way up from childhood poverty to become a respected clergyman and hymn songwriter.
Local Church
Kimberly Pitcher-Crago (left) and Ellen Hawes present a liturgical dance during a 2002 service of repentance by Foundry United Methodist Church at Asbury United Methodist Church in Washington. In the 19th century, racial discrimination at Foundry led to the formation of Asbury and later John Wesley AME Zion. File photo © Jay Mallin.

To fight racism, 3 churches reckon with past

Discrimination at a prominent D.C. church led two African American congregations to break away in the 1800s. Now the three are reconnecting.