Out of Saturday’s General Conference Shame, God Keeps Door Open

A few words describe the debacle that emerged from Saturday night’s failed debate over restructuring The United Methodist Church: Disgust. Mistrust. Manipulation.

The chaotic ending of the work of the 2012 General Conference’s General Administration Committee puts to shame the worst machinations we all decry in the today’s secular politics.

This was Holy Conferencing at its absolute worst.

The committee’s failure to reach any kind of agreement on a better structure for our denomination reflects how much we have come to allow manipulation, back-room dealing, whisper campaigning and a lust for control and power take over our legislative processes.

When I say we, I mean we: Left, Right, Clergy, Lay, Bishops, The Connectional Table, and General Agency executives, staff and board members.

Yet, out of the chaos, I believe there is a solution out there. It’s contained in pieces of the IOT (Interim Operations Team), MFSA (Methodist Federation for Social Action), and Plan B Coalition proposals.

Out of Saturday night’s chaos, God remains present, offering another opportunity to discern God’s will for each of us individually, and for the denomination we all profess to love.

It’s time to set egos aside, put the political and right wing, left wing and turkey wing agendas back in the briefcases computer file folders, and seek where God is leading us. Bring all sides to the table – God’s table – with a strong mediator, and work it out. Then bring it to the floor of General Conference.

Nothing less than the unity of the church is at stake. If we fail, the church fails. If we fail, we will be letting down every United Methodist who voted to send us here to discern a better direction for our denomination. We will be letting down the legacy of John Wesley, who shows us the importance of being connected to one another around the world. And we will be letting ourselves down, for we know we can do better.

We are in a place that reminds me of a devotion I read from shortdailydevotionscom: “When our hope is placed in anything less than the perfect God of the universe, we will live in the darkness of dissatisfaction.”

Taking liberty with Psalm 130:7 from the Common English Bible: “United Methodists, trust the Lord! God is always merciful. God has the power to save you.”

Always.


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Worship
Retired Bishop Peggy A. Johnson. Photo courtesy of the author.

Helping people ‘hear the Gospel’ in new ways

May is National Speech-Language-Hearing Month, a good time for United Methodist churches to examine ways to improve hearing accessibility.
Social Concerns
The Rev. Christopher P. Momany. Photo by Kristen Schell.

For every righteous ‘no,’ there must be a holy ‘yes’

Methodism’s Wesleyan-Holiness heritage holds principles that can be applied to today’s struggles around human dignity.
Church History
The Methodist Church’s 1956 General Conference meets from April 25 to May 7 in the municipal auditorium in Minneapolis. On May 4, the first Friday of the legislative assembly, the delegates voted to make women eligible for full clergy rights. “Now it is up to us to prove in clear and deep witness to the whole church our consecration and our loyal devotion to the work of the Kingdom of God,” said Margaret Henrichsen, a General Conference visitor, after the vote. In 1967, she became the first U.S. woman appointed district superintendent. Photo courtesy of Archives and History.

Why the 1956 women-clergy vote matters

Seventy years ago, the Methodist Church supported full conference membership for women clergy — a decision that would have a resounding impact when The United Methodist Church formed in 1968 and even today.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved