United Methodists speak out about Dallas police shooting

The Rev. Abril Goforth (left) and the Rev. Edlen Cowley lead a march of United Methodists from Dallas police headquarters to the apartment complex where a white officer shot and killed a black man in his residence. The group called for justice for 26-year-old victim Botham Jean. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.
The Rev. Abril Goforth (left) and the Rev. Edlen Cowley lead a march of United Methodists from Dallas police headquarters to the apartment complex where a white officer shot and killed a black man in his residence. The group called for justice for 26-year-old victim Botham Jean. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

A diverse group of United Methodists, including about 60 clergy, gathered at Dallas police headquarters to raise concerns about the handling of a white police officer’s fatal shooting of a young black man in his residence.

“This is not about a rush to justice,” said the Rev. Edlen Cowley, organizer of the Sept. 19 event and president of the North Texas Conference African American Clergy Fellowship. “This is about Lady Justice and wanting to see that justice happen.”

Cowley and a white colleague, the Rev. Abril Goforth, led a hymn-singing march to the nearby apartment complex where the killing occurred.

“I can no longer remain silent … I stand for young African-American men who continue to live in a world fraught with danger, and I stand with their mothers, who live in terror,” said Goforth, pastor of First United Methodist in Lewisville, Texas, in remarks before the march.

Amber Guyger, a four-year veteran of the police force, shot and killed Botham Jean on the evening of Sept. 6 at the Southside Flats apartment complex.

Guyger, who had finished a long shift, immediately reported the incident. She said she mistakenly entered the apartment thinking it was her own, noticed a figure she thought was a burglar, called out a command which was ignored and fired twice.

The officer’s apartment was directly one floor below Jean’s.

Jean, a 26-year-old native of the Caribbean island St. Lucia, was a risk insurance associate at PricewaterhouseCoopers, and active as a song leader at Dallas West Church of Christ.

A delay in Guyger’s arrest, her charge of manslaughter rather than murder and her having been placed on administrative leave rather than being dismissed have led many to accuse authorities of preferential treatment for the officer.

Some have seen the release of a search warrant showing marijuana in Jean’s apartment as an effort to besmirch him, though police and the media have noted that such documents are routinely reported public records.

The Rev. Ouida Lee (speaking) draws a strong response from United Methodists gathered outside Dallas police headquarters.  A diverse group of North Texas Conference clergy spoke and marched, demanding justice for Botham Jean, a 26-year-old black man killed in his Dallas apartment by a white police officer. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

The Rev. Ouida Lee (speaking) draws a strong response from United Methodists gathered outside Dallas police headquarters. A diverse group of North Texas Conference clergy spoke and marched, demanding justice for Botham Jean, a 26-year-old black man killed in his Dallas apartment by a white police officer. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

The killing and its aftermath have drawn national media coverage and raised tensions in Dallas, prompting a range of rallies and marches.

Some high-profile Dallas clergy, including United Methodists, recently signed a commentary published in the Dallas Morning News, which began: “In our city’s current tragedy, we believe that Officer Amber Guyger’s blue uniform should grant her no advantage in the current investigation and upcoming prosecution.”

Cowley, who has a cross-cultural appointment as pastor of Fellowship United Methodist Church in the suburban community of Trophy Club, Texas, organized not only the United Methodist march but also a letter signed by more than 100 North Texas Conference clergy.

The letter, addressed to Dallas County District Attorney Faith Johnson, Dallas Mayor Mike Rawlings and Dallas police Chief U. Renee Hall, called for Guyger to be prosecuted “to the full extent of the law.”

The signers said they side with Jean’s mother, Allison Jean, in calling for a full accounting of the incident.

“The impact of Mr. Jean’s killing is growing, particularly in our churches and communities,” the letter said. “Our African-American youth and young adults are understandably upset as they now feel that if Mr. Jean can be killed in his own apartment, they may not even be safe in their own homes.”

The letter also promised prayers for Guyger, her family and the investigating authorities, which have included the Texas Rangers.

Cowley said the United Methodists’ letter and march were an important witness. Speakers before the march included African-American, white and Hispanic clergy.

“It’s a very intentional opportunity for the diversity of The United Methodist Church to be on display,” he said.

North Texas Conference Bishop Michael McKee was traveling but sent his support, said his assistant, the Rev. Andy Lewis.

Lewis joined in the march and offered remarks.

“As the investigation continues, we will have patience and we will have vigilance, because injustice can rear its head at any turn,” Lewis said.

“We will support the district attorney and her team and the city leadership, and we will be watching. We will be looking for the highest standards of ethics and professionalism as they pursue this case.”

Hodges is a Dallas-based writer for United Methodist News Service. Contact him at 615-742-5470 or newsdesk@umcom.org. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests

Latest News

Human Sexuality
In a skit for Do No Harm 2018, Paul Ballard plays "Pastor John" and the Rev. Sally Bevill plays "Sally," two fictional characters whose counseling session crosses into romance. Ballard and Bevill joined others from the Mississippi Conference in staging the short drama, aimed at prompting discussion about sexual misconduct in the church. Do No Harm is The United Methodist Church's every-few-years sexual ethics summit, and this year's was held in San Antonio. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

Timing right for sexual ethics summit

With #MeToo movement as backdrop, The United Methodist Church's Do No Harm conference draws engaged crowd.
Mission and Ministry
Ganta United Methodist Hospital in Liberia is among the agencies and programs that will be receiving new grants from the United Methodist Committee on Relief. The hospital will receive $431,042 for the second phase of renovations. 2017 file photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

New UMCOR grants target crisis areas, basic needs

United Methodist relief and development agency assists vulnerable populations with emergency needs but also focuses on preparedness and sustainability projects.
Church History
(Left to right) Central United Methodist Church in Luanda, Angola, photo by Mike DuBose; food distribution site for the United Methodist Committee on Relief, Dagami, Philippines, photo by Mike DuBose; the Rev. Shalom Agtarap, photo by Paul Jeffrey; stained glass cross and flame, photo by Kathleen Barry.

Ask The UMC: Has The United Methodist Church always had an official symbol like the cross and flame?

The official insignia of The United Methodist Church has been the Cross and Flame since its founding in 1968. The symbols and seals for other predecessor denominations were generally varied in form and use.

Sign up for our newsletter!

SUBSCRIBE