United Methodists share story of daughter’s murder

A United Methodist couple from Michigan drove 600 miles to celebrate their daughter’s short life and share the story of her murder as part of a summit on gun violence.

Chris Schwind and her husband, the Rev. Tim Woycik, attended the joint summit on gun violence sponsored by the Brady Campaign to End Gun Violence and Americans for Responsible Solutions, an advocacy group created in 2013 by former U.S. Representative Gabby Giffords after the Sandy Hook shooting in December 2012. Giffords herself survived a mass shooting in 2011.

While they were in Washington, Schwind and Woycik, pastor of Trinity United Methodist Church in Chesaning, Michigan, met with staff of their U.S. senators and congressman.

“I’ve never done anything like this,” Schwind said during the bus ride from their hotel to Capitol Hill. “I’m not a polished speaker; I don’t like speaking in public. I’m an RN, but I’m a mom and I’m on a mission.”

In meetings with staffers for Democratic Sens. Debbie Stabenow and Gary Peters, as well as Republican Rep. John Moolenaar, Schwind told her story. Stabenow is herself a United Methodist.

Photo of Holly Schwind, courtesy of Chris Schwind.

Photo of Holly Schwind, courtesy of Chris Schwind.  

“I’m here to honor my daughter, Holly,” Schwind said. “I’m here to be a voice for her.”

Holly Schwind was murdered by John Smith, her ex-boyfriend, on Labor Day weekend 2004. After killing Holly, Smith committed suicide.

Schwind spoke of how Holly graduated from high school in 1992 and earned a master’s degree in business in college. She also spoke about how Holly was a homecoming queen in both high school and college. “She wasn’t the type of girl to be murdered,” Schwind said.

But Holly had met Smith and they dated for about a year. On the day before she was murdered, Holly told her mom that he had a temper.

“And I thought, ‘Oh, good for you; you saw it; you broke up with him,’” Schwind said.

A friend of Smith bought a gun in Texas and gave it to him there. Smith then drove to Michigan. The murder was committed in Au Gres, a small community on the shores of Lake Huron, where there hadn’t been a murder for more than 30 years. The police didn’t know how to handle it, her mother noted.

“I’m part of a club that nobody wants to belong to,” Schwind said. “But I don’t want to live in the tragedy of her death. I want to celebrate her life. I owe this to her.”

Woycik also shared his experience of serving in United Methodist churches in Michigan for more than 30 years. Many of his members, he said, are responsible gun owners and hunters.

“Some of those people in the church I now serve have been able to say, ‘We understand about background checks. We support that; we want to see that happen,’ ” Woycik said. “They feel that every time something happens, that they’re going to be singled out. They’re responsible gun owners, so they support these things that we bring up today.”

Woycik added that coming to Washington to support his wife also stirred up some advocacy juices within him.

THE CHURCH'S POSITION

The United Methodist Church’s Book of Resolutions includes a lengthy statement on gun violence that calls for background checks and waiting periods for gun purchases. It also calls on the church to advocate for the eventual reduction of the availability of guns. 

“Like my wife, Chris, I’m really tired of hearing about the number of victims that there are due to gun violence that just doesn’t need to be,” he said after the visits. “There’s far too many people who have guns who shouldn’t have them. It’s time for me to stand up in ways I haven’t before.”

Woycik believes the issue isn’t something that God would want anyone to ignore. Though he’s never preached about gun violence, he has written letters to the editor and articles in church newsletters.

“But to preach on it, in specifics, no; I haven’t,” he said. “That’s probably going to change.”

The man who murdered her daughter, Schwind said, would have passed a background check in Michigan. He had no criminal record, she said, but he did suffer from mental illness. “The message, for me, is that we need more strict laws regarding background checks for mentally ill people.”

Some people immediately assume that discussions about gun violence mean that others want to take away their guns. Schwind pointed out. “That’s not what we’re talking about here,” she said,

But she expressed concern about attempts to roll back requirements on background checks, particularly for those already been declared mentally incompetent. “I didn’t really know about that before coming here, so now I really want to pursue that.”

Schwind created a scholarship foundation in her daughter’s memory soon after she was murdered. To date, that foundation has paid more than $58,000 for young women to attend school.

“That’s on a very small scale compared to what I see here (at the summit),” she said. “Now, I’m going to get involved in the Michigan group and go to Lansing to speak at our state capital.”

“I know that my story is not unique,” Schwind said, “but it is unique to me and it’s personal to me. So it’s not like I’m just here saying, ‘yeah, yeah, yeah, we need strong laws.’ It’s personal to me! My daughter was murdered.”

Alsgaard is managing editor in the Ministry of Communications for the Baltimore-Washington Conference. To get more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests.

News contact: Vicki Brown, 615-742-5472 or [email protected].


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Violence
The Rev. Joseph M. De Castro is the pastor at First United Methodist Church in Dubai. His congregation of mostly migrant workers and others who live in the United Arab Emirates and surrounding countries have been caught in the middle of war. Photo courtesy of the TFUMC Dubai Media Team.

Middle East United Methodists feel brunt of war

Filipino United Methodists who work and worship along the Arabian Peninsula have been caught in the crossfire of the U.S.-Israel war with Iran.
Mission and Ministry
Bishop João Sambo of Mozambique (right) and Bishop Emmanuel Sinzohagera of Burundi (center) distribute cans of vegetable oil at the Musenyi camp in Burundi. The bishops were among a United Methodist delegation who visited the camp in March to offer physical and spiritual support to refugees fleeing conflict in eastern Congo. Global Missionary Abro Patrick stands to the left. Photo courtesy of the communications department of the Burundi-Rwanda Episcopal Area.

Church supports Congolese refugees in Burundi

The United Methodist Church, with support from UMCOR, provides vital infrastructure and food to the Musenyi camp, which has doubled its population because of ongoing conflicts in eastern Congo.
Violence
The Rev. Bob Anders (at left) leads a time of prayer on April 3, Good Friday at Cedaredge Community United Methodist Church in Cedaredge, Colo. The church displayed on its steps a memorial showing pairs of shoes to represent the 168 children and teachers killed Feb. 28 in the bombing of the girls’ school in Minab, Iran. Photos of the memorial went viral on social media. Amid the tenuous ceasefire, United Methodists continue to speak out against the war and especially threats of genocide. Photo courtesy of Anders, Cedaredge Community United Methodist Church.

United Methodists confront Iran war’s impact

With the ceasefire on shaky ground and no deal in sight, United Methodists are praying for peace as they’ve done since the beginning of the U.S.-Israel war against Iran. They also are speaking out against disregard for human life.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved