United Methodists join in Trump rebuke

Christy Obiageri Ogbuehi, a member of Hamilton Park United Methodist Church here, has a plea for President Trump regarding Africa and specifically her native country of Nigeria.

“Stop living in ignorance,” said Ogbuehi, who arrived in the U.S. in 1988 and is now a citizen. “Visit Nigeria. If you don’t want to go, talk to the Nigerians who are here. Talk to them about their lives. Talk to them about their children. Talk to them about how they have contributed to this society.”

Obguehi is one of many United Methodists in the U.S. and beyond who criticized Trump’s reported use of a vulgarity and the overall tone and substance of his remarks about African countries and Haiti during a private a White House meeting last week with senators trying to reach a bipartisan immigration deal.

The United Methodist Council of Bishops reacted swiftly.

The Rev. Sheron Patterson (l), pastor of Hamilton Park United Methodist Church in Dallas, posed Jan. 15, 2017, with church member  Christy Obiageri Obguehi, a U.S. citizen born in Nigeria. Both women were critical of President Trump for reported remarks about African countries and Haiti. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

The Rev. Sheron Patterson (l), pastor of Hamilton Park United Methodist Church in Dallas, posed Jan. 15, 2017, with church member  Christy Obiageri Obguehi, a U.S. citizen born in Nigeria. Both women were critical of President Trump for reported remarks about African countries and Haiti. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

“As reported, President Trump’s words are not only offensive and harmful, they are racist,” the council said in a statement released by its president, Bishop Bruce R. Ough. “We call upon Christians, especially United Methodists, to condemn this characterization and further call for President Trump to apologize.”

United Methodists in Africa also weighed in.

The Rev. Kombi Ramazani Simon, of the Democratic Republic of Congo’s Kivu Conference, expressed shock and disappointment at Trump’s reported statements.

“I ask President Trump to revise his words … that we can live in harmony,” the Congolese pastor said.

The Washington Post was the first to report that Trump, in the Jan. 11 meeting, argued the U.S. should look to countries like Norway for immigrants, not to African countries.

“Why are we having all these people from (expletive) countries come here?” Trump said, according to the newspaper’s unnamed sources.

The Post also reported that Trump said Haiti should not be a part of an immigration deal.

“Why do we need more Haitians?” the newspaper quoted Trump.

Trump acknowledged taking a hard line, saying he was protecting U.S. interests, but denied using the vulgar language. Two Republican senators and Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen backed up Trump.

But Sen. Dick Durbin, a Democrat from Illinois, was in the meeting and verified the reporting.

“In the course of his comments, (Trump) said things which were hate-filled, vile and racist,” Durbin said.

Durbin also said that South Carolina Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham was in the meeting and stood up to Trump about the language.

“Following comments by the president, I said my piece directly to him,” Graham said in a statement. “The president and all those attending know what I said and how I feel.”

The Rev. Sheron Patterson, pastor of Hamilton Park United Methodist Church in Dallas, took to the pulpit on Jan. 15, 2017, and criticized President Trump for his reported remarks about African countries and Haiti. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

The Rev. Sheron Patterson, pastor of Hamilton Park United Methodist Church in Dallas, took to the pulpit on Jan. 15, 2017, and criticized President Trump for his reported remarks about African countries and Haiti. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

As the dispute continued, United Methodists joined the voices nationally and internationally criticizing Trump.

The Wesleyan Covenant Association, an unofficial evangelical caucus of the denomination, issued a statement saying in part: “Because of the specific and pointed comments directed at African nations and Haiti, we repudiate the recent remarks attributed to President Donald Trump. We join with legislators from both parties who believe that these words are unworthy of the office of the President. “

The Rev. Susan Henry-Crowe, top executive of the United Methodist Board of Church and Society, was with other denominational agency leaders at Lydia Patterson Institute, a United Methodist school in El Paso, Texas, when Trump’s reported remarks began to spread.

She said she considered it “particularly shocking” to get the news there, given the school’s long history of educating impoverished students from both El Paso and Ciudad Juárez, Mexico, just across the border.

Henry-Crowe also said: “I have been blessed to travel to many communities and countries in Africa, the Caribbean and Central America during my life and work in The United Methodist Church. The comments made by President Trump could not be farther from the truth. And labeling white people (or predominantly white countries) as superior is racism. Plain and simple.”

The United Methodist Commission on Religion and Race condemned the reported remarks and Thomas Kemper, top executive of the denomination’s Board of Global Ministries, shared his concerns with the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

“(Trump’s) statement erodes trust in the United States in general and makes life and work in dangerous and volatile areas even more difficult,” Kemper said.

As of 2015, The United Methodist Church had 5.6 million members in its non-U.S. central conferences, with the overwhelming majority of those in Africa.

Many U.S. churches are active in mission work in Africa and Haiti, and the denomination founded and continues to support and operate Africa University, in Zimbabwe.

The Rev. Julius S. Nelson, a United Methodist pastor and educator in Liberia, said Africans should separate the American people from divisive rhetoric attributed to President Trump.

The Rev. Julius S. Nelson, a United Methodist pastor and educator in Liberia, said Africans should separate the American people from divisive rhetoric attributed to President Trump. "There are good people in America who see us as God's children and therefore believe that we are one," Nelson said. File photo courtesy of E. Julu Swen, UMNS.

Bishop L. Jonathan Holston of the South Carolina Conference underscored those connections in addressing the controversy.

“Thousands of South Carolina United Methodists have had the privilege to have served the people of Haiti, multiple African nations and many countries on several continents through mission work,” Holston said in a statement. “We have walked and lived among the inhabitants of these nations, and we know them to be children of God, worthy of our respect.”

Ecumenical groups such as the National Council of Churches and World Council of Churches condemned the reported Trump remarks, and the WCC’s top executive spoke personally.

“As a Norwegian, and as general secretary of the international fellowship in the WCC, I don’t accept that my country or any country is used in expressions to undermine the dignity of other people and other countries,” said the Rev. Olav Fykse Tveit.

Some United Methodists in Africa offered a different perspective on the controversy.

At McBride United Methodist Church, in Jalingo, Nigeria, Bubajoda Mafindi said longstanding corruption among African leaders “gave Trump the audacity to insult Africans.”

The Rev. Julius S. Nelson, a United Methodist pastor and educator in Liberia, encouraged Africans to separate the American people from Trump’s rhetoric.

“There are good people in America who see us as God’s children and therefore believe that we are one,” Nelson said.

The Rev. Sheron Patterson, issued a rebuke to Trump from the Hamilton Park United Methodist pulpit on Jan. 14. Then she asked all the African-born members in worship that day to the altar.

As the small group arrived to a standing ovation from the congregation, Patterson said: “Jesus loves you, God made you, we embrace you. We are with you 100 percent.”

Sam Hodges, a writer for United Methodist News Service writer, lives in Dallas. E. Julu Swen, Sharon Adamu and Philippe Kituka Lolonga contributed from Africa.  Contact Hodges at (615) 742-5470 or [email protected]


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

UMNEWS-SUBSCRIPTION
Theology and Education
Theocracy Tasweranadzo, 10, raises his hand in class at Munyarari Primary School in Mutare, Zimbabwe. A former student at The United Methodist Church’s mission school has created a scholarship program for the three best students in each class. Photo by Kudzai Chingwe, UM News.

Mission school alumnus gives students a boost

Now a prominent businessman, Isaiah Musabayana launched a scholarship program for students at two United Methodist mission schools he attended in the mid-1980s.
Mission and Ministry
The Revs. Daniel Mutidzawanda (right) and Zebediah Marewangepo pray over the first portion of the harvest, which is given to God, at Chisipiti United Methodist Church in Zimbabwe. Photo by Kudzai Chingwe, UM News.

Zimbabwe United Methodists share bounty

Members of the Zimbabwe Episcopal Area embrace the concept of “first fruits,” giving the initial produce of the harvest to God and the church.
Global Health
Dr. Patrick Kilunji, director of United Methodist Shungu Clinic in Kamina, Congo, shows a pregnant woman how to take her own blood pressure at the clinic. In partnership with Harper Hill Global and other organizations, the clinic and North Katanga Episcopal Area are helping educate people in rural villages about hypertension and the risks for pregnant women. Photo by the Rev. Betty Kazadi Musau, UM News.

Hypertension campaign saves lives in Congo

A partnership among the North Katanga United Methodist Church, Harper Hill Global and others provides lifesaving information on how risky high blood pressure can be for pregnant women.