Timing right for sexual ethics summit

In a skit for Do No Harm 2018, Paul Ballard plays "Pastor John" and the Rev. Sally Bevill plays "Sally," two fictional characters whose counseling session crosses into romance. Ballard and Bevill joined others from the Mississippi Conference in staging the short drama, aimed at prompting discussion about sexual misconduct in the church. Do No Harm is The United Methodist Church's every-few-years sexual ethics summit, and this year's was held in San Antonio. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.
In a skit for Do No Harm 2018, Paul Ballard plays "Pastor John" and the Rev. Sally Bevill plays "Sally," two fictional characters whose counseling session crosses into romance. Ballard and Bevill joined others from the Mississippi Conference in staging the short drama, aimed at prompting discussion about sexual misconduct in the church. Do No Harm is The United Methodist Church's every-few-years sexual ethics summit, and this year's was held in San Antonio. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

Talk about catching the wave.

The United Methodist Church holds a sexual ethics summit every few years, but the one last week in San Antonio gained urgency from the #MeToo Movement, the Kavanaugh hearings, the Bill Cosby sentencing and yet another round of sex abuse-related scandal in the Catholic Church.

Those events were only passingly referenced at Do No Harm 2018, coordinated by the Commission on the Status and Role of Women and the United Methodist Interagency Sexual Ethics Task Force.

But they charged the atmosphere.

“There’s a different energy here,” said Dawn Wiggins Hare, top executive of the commission. “It’s a positive and hopeful and determined energy to go out and do something and make a difference in the world and church.”

This year’s Do No Harm, held Oct. 11-13, follows summits by that name in 2006, 2011 and 2015.

Some 280 people, mostly clergy and conference staff, attended this time, crowding the main conference hall of an airport Holiday Inn, as well as smaller meeting rooms for breakout sessions.

The Rev. Ruth Marston-Bihl came from the First United Methodist Church in Olympia, Washington.

“There’s no way I could not be here,” she said. “Women are no longer keeping quiet about what’s happening to them. … In the past three weeks, seven women have come forward to talk to me about their sexual assault or rape.”

The Rev. Ruth Marston-Bihl takes her turn at the microphone during a discussion period at Do No Harm, The United Methodist Church's sexual ethics summit. The event drew about 280 people, including seven United Methodist bishops. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS. 
The Rev. Ruth Marston-Bihl takes her turn at the microphone during a discussion period at Do No Harm, The United Methodist Church's sexual ethics summit. The event drew about 280 people, including seven United Methodist bishops. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

The Rev. Idda John Ngowi, of the North Katanga Conference in the Democratic Republic of Congo, came to gather ideas for addressing sexual harassment and abuse in Africa, including in the church.

“We need help on this subject,” the United Methodist pastor said through a translator. “The response is not there.”

In January, the Council of Bishops joined the Commission on the Status and Role of Women in issuing a statement supporting the #MeToo and #ChurchToo movements and strongly encouraging reporting of sexual misconduct, including within the church.

Many bishops sent cabinet members to the San Antonio gathering, and seven bishops attended.

“Persons’ lives are changed by boundary crossings and sexual misconduct,” said Bishop LaTrelle Easterling of the Baltimore-Washington Conference. “Everybody should be prioritizing this (response) work.”

The Rio Texas Conference’s Bishop Robert Schnase preached at opening worship, listing warning signs for conferences insufficiently attentive to clergy sexual misconduct and calling for a “conversion of imagination” to see the problem more clearly.

He also referred without specificity to recent news events.

“I thought we would have been farther along by now,” Schnase said.

Clergy sexual misconduct is a focus of Do No Harm, and this year’s conference featured a short play by the Rev. Walt Frazier, a Mississippi Conference deacon and licensed counselor.

In the fictional skit, acted by clergy and laity of the Mississippi Conference, the pastor of the aptly named Wilderness United Methodist Church ends up romantically involved with a church member who comes for counseling about her unraveling marriage.

That he crossed the line is clear, but the question-and-answer period yielded plenty of questions and comments about how the matter was reported and how the church and conference responded.

The Rev. Sally Bevill, pastor of Hawkins United Methodist Church in Vicksburg, Mississippi, played the woman who sought counseling. She noted that the troupe had performed the same skit for the Mississippi Conference, but got a much stronger reaction at Do No Harm.

“The people gathered in this conference are so aware of what’s going on,” Bevill said.

Hare describes Do No Harm as a “train the trainer” event, and much of the discussion went to preparing conferences and churches for dealing effectively with reported misconduct. For example, conference response teams shared best practices for helping congregations reeling from reported abuse by clergy or church staff.

The conference also offered a detailed explanation of church law and policies, as well advice from insurance company experts.

Schnase and others suggested conferences vary widely in their sensitivity and commitment to dealing with sexual misconduct.

“We pat ourselves on the back a lot in the Methodist Church. We say we’re really far ahead of the Baptists. … And yet, we’re still light years away from where we need to be,” said Bill Waddell, lawyer for the Council of Bishops.

Plenary speakers included Jennifer Freyd, a psychology professor at the University of Oregon who has researched and written extensively about sexual harassment and assault, and institutions’ failure to address it.

Though she has focused on colleges and universities, Freyd offered a range of suggestions for how other institutions, including the church, can better respond.

Dawn Wiggins Hare, top executive of the General Commission on the Status and Role of Women, speaks at the 2018 Do No Harm conference of The United Methodist Church. The sexual ethics summit drew clergy and laity from across the denomination, including the Central Conferences. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS. 
Dawn Wiggins Hare, top executive of the General Commission on the Status and Role of Women, speaks at the 2018 Do No Harm conference of The United Methodist Church. The sexual ethics summit drew clergy and laity from across the denomination, including the Central Conferences. Photo by Sam Hodges, UMNS.

“Bear witness, be accountable and apologize,” she laid out as crucial steps for leaders.

There was discussion too of how the church can better assist members or visitors who report sexual harassment or assault in family or workplace settings.

“As a pastor, I have had the privilege to bear witness to these stories, and to hold women in a place of empowerment and encouragement,” said the Rev. Rebekah Solar, a licensed local pastor in the Upper New York Conference.

One workshop dealt with how the church can better support clergy accused of sexual conduct. The Rev. Scott Campbell led the session, drawing on his experience representing accused clergy in church trials.

“To have a venue at which people are being exposed to the concerns, the needs, the rights of people who are victimized, but to also talk about the converse of that, in human terms, is a major thing, and I’m grateful,” Campbell said.

The conference included the premiere of a short animated film, aimed at prompting candid discussion about sexual misconduct, by Peabody Award-winning producer Firdaus Kharas.

The Virginia Conference’s Bishop Sharma Lewis, preaching in closing worship, asked that The United Methodist Church become a prophetic voice regarding sexual misconduct. She urged more of a financial commitment, too.

“There’s not enough money in this Commission (on the Status and Role of Women) to do the work that they are called to do for this denomination,” Lewis said.

The commission has a website for sharing sexual ethics resources, and Hare said planning is underway for building on the momentum of Do No Harm 2018.

The Rev. Bob Smith left the event with his own action plan.

“We don’t have an official response team in Alaska,” said Smith, pastor of Turnagain United Methodist in Anchorage. “We definitely will.”

Hodges is a Dallas-based writer for United Methodist News Service. Contact him at 615-742-5470 or newsdesk@umcom.org. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Weekly Digests. 

Sign up for our newsletter!

SUBSCRIBE

Latest News

Social Concerns
Christina Schmidt, a volunteer with the Malawi Conference women’s organization, teaches young women how to make meatballs during training in Blantyre, Malawi. Photo by Francis Nkhoma, UMNS.

Young underprivileged women gain hope in Malawi

Malawi Conference training focuses on education, gender-based violence, dating and courtship, and spirituality.
Local Church
The Rev. Cynthia Abrams, a United Methodist clergywoman and social justice advocate, is pictured in her office at the Board of Church and Society in 2012. Abrams died Jan. 11 at the age of 58. File photo by Kathleen Barry, UMNS.

Native American clergywoman took justice to heart

The Rev. Cynthia Abrams is being remembered as a committed, compassionate leader who found her voice through The United Methodist Church.
Mission and Ministry
Gilbert Hanke, top staff executive of United Methodist Men. 2012 file photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS

Commentary: There is danger when there is gender imbalance

The role of all men and all women within The United Methodist Church is to be disciples who make more disciples, writes Gilbert C. Hanke of United Methodist Men.