Updated April 11: Scouting group loses United Methodist affiliation

Editor's note: The story has been updated to include more recent membership figures for the National Association of United Methodist Scouters and some more details from Gil Hanke, the top executive of United Methodist Men.

After years of tension, a scouting organization has lost its affiliation with the Commission on United Methodist Men and other United Methodist organizations.

The National Association of United Methodist Scouters is no longer affiliated with the commission, the National Association of Conference Presidents of United Methodist Men and the United Methodist Men Foundation, said an April 10 news release.

Because the association has no formal relationship with any national entity of The United Methodist Church, the statement said, it is “prohibited from using the United Methodist name and logo.”

Leaders of both United Methodist Men and the national association said that the dispute has absolutely nothing to do with the controversial decision made last year by the National Council of the Boy Scouts of America to lift a ban on gay members.

At heart, leaders say, the dispute is about the role of an affiliate of an agency in The United Methodist Church.

“Are they a subordinate group that is meant to provide assistance and manpower for what the board is doing?” said Gil Hanke, the top executive of the Commission of United Methodist Men. “Or are they to have a relationship that is different, which is controlling part of the ministry of one of the boards and agencies?”

Phil Craig, president of the national association, said members of his group feel that the commission “wants to dictate everything we do, and we think that’s wrong.”

Craig is a lifelong United Methodist, an Eagle Scout and former Scoutmaster. He continues serve on the board of the National Order of the Arrow, the Boy Scouts’ honor society.

Both Craig and Hanke agreed they expect the change to have little impact on the youth-service organizations supported by local United Methodist churches. But they also agreed the break is regrettable.

The Tennessee-based association long has raised funds for and distributed Scriptures that include Psalms, Proverbs and the New Testament to Boy Scout High Adventure programs such as Philmont Scout Ranch and Florida Sea Base and other scouting ministries. The group also has helped promote Scouting Ministries Sunday and the denomination’s Programs of Religious Activities with Youth (P.R.A.Y.) award program, which honors participants in church school, youth ministry and scouting ministries.

Hanke said on April 11 that the United Methodist Men Foundation gave the association $10,000 for the Bible ministry in 2013. He also said the foundation, the commission and association plan to continue to provide the Scriptures that will be presented at Philmont Scout Ranch by a United Methodist chaplain, recruited and trained by the commission.

Ultimately, Hanke said he expected the commission’s office of scouting ministries to continue the work without the association’s help. “All the tasks that were part of scouting ministries six months ago are continuing and continuing to expand,” Hanke said.

Longtime tensions

The national association is about 30 years old, said Craig. Minutes from a 2012 meeting showed the group had 416 total members. 

The group predates the founding of the Commission on United Methodist Men — which General Conference, the denomination’s top lawmaking body, established as a general church agency in 1996.

The United Methodist Book of Discipline, which contains the church’s policies and procedures, charges the Commission on United Methodist Men with providing resources and support to scouting ministries. The book lists Boy Scouts of America, Girl Scouts of the USA, Big Brothers Big Sisters Amachi Partnership, Camp Fire and 4-H among the civic youth-serving organizations the denomination supports.

The book says "Civic youth-serving agencies and scouting ministries offer another setting for ministry to children, youth, their leaders and their families."

Both the association and commission have worked to support those ministries, but Hanke and Craig agree that tensions between the two groups go back to almost the beginning of the commission and have lasted through multiple changes in leadership.

Craig said association members often felt the commission’s scouting ministries office “denigrated” their contributions.

Dispute reaches breaking point

Matters came to a head not long after Craig was elected the group’s president in July last year.

The commission asked Craig to attend its September board meeting, where the board presented him with eight tasks for the association’s board to complete to maintain its affiliation with United Methodist Men.

“It was the hope that the actions we requested would align the two organizations,” Hanke said. “It was the expectation of the board at the end of the meeting those actions would be completed by Dec. 15.”

That did not happen

The actions United Methodist Men wanted related to business practices and coordination, Hanke said. Craig said the tasks included getting the group’s paperwork in order with the Internal Revenue Service, going through board training and centering its fundraising out of the commission’s office in Nashville.

Craig some of the bylaw changes the commission required his board had already completed years earlier and association board members had just gone through training that summer. A particular sticking point, he said, was the commission’s requirement that three of its board members be added to the association’s board.

Craig said his group’s bylaws require that its board members have representation on the commission too, but that didn’t happen when new commission members were elected in 2012.

The commission was one of eight general agencies with legislation approved at the 2012 General Conference to reduce its board size. The result was that for the first time, association members were not guaranteed a place on the commission’s board or its executive committee, Craig said.

Craig said his board thinks the commission violated due process in making its demands. Hanke said the commission gave the association every chance to bring its work into alignment.

Craig said the association is considering appealing the United Methodist Men decision to the Judicial Council, The United Methodist Church’s top court. He said his group also hopes to affiliate with another United Methodist entity.

But Craig also stressed that he hopes the situation can “be resolved without any problems in the church.”

“I don’t want people taking sides,” he said. “They have their ministry, and we have ours.”

Hanke said the commission will maintain its “commitment to serving youth — those youth in our United Methodist churches and those in the communities surrounding our United Methodist churches.”

*Hahn is a multimedia news reporter for United Methodist News Service. Contact her at (615) 742-5470 or [email protected].

Sign up for our newsletter!

Social Concerns
The coronavirus pandemic has presented unique challenges to the U.S. census this year. Robbinsville United Methodist Church is one of the churches trying to help make sure everyone counts. Photo illustration by Kathleen Barry, UM News.

Churches see census as part of their mission

United Methodists across the U.S. are helping hard-to-count people ‘come to their census.’ In doing so, they hope to strengthen their communities.
Mission and Ministry
The Rev. Ingrid McIntyre shares the story of the micro house community for homeless respite care under construction at Glencliff United Methodist Church in Nashville, Tenn. Photo by Kathleen Barry, UM News.

Church building micro home village for homeless

The homes will serve as bridge housing for homeless people to recover from medical issues as they await permanent housing.
General Church
Kevin Dunn presents an overview of U.S. United Methodist membership data to the General Council on Finance and Administration board during its Nov. 15 meeting in Nashville, Tenn. He is the agency’s director of data services. Among the bright spots he pointed to was the church’s growth in Hispanic and multiracial members. Photo by Kathleen Barry, UM News.

US dips below majority of membership

United Methodist leaders project that by now at least half of the denomination lives outside the U.S.