Petitioners ask bishop to end clergy trials

PHILADELPHIA (UMNS) — Two days after a United Methodist pastor, the Rev. Frank Schaefer, was found guilty of violating the denomination’s lawbook for officiating at his son’s same-sex wedding, representatives of Faithful America presented United Methodist Bishop Peggy Johnson with a petition signed by more than 19,000 calling for an end to clergy trials.

It was learned, however, during the presentation of the petition that a new “supervisory action” has been started against another United Methodist pastor.

On Nov. 9, more than 50 United Methodist clergy participated in the same sex wedding of Richard Kevin Taylor and William Robert Gatewood at Arch Street United Methodist Church in Philadelphia.

Johnson was asked if she was considering charges against those pastors and she said a “supervisory action” had been started on one of the clergy who had participated. She did not identify the pastor, and, under church law cannot make public the name.

Faithful America is a non-denominational, online community that describes itself as dedicated to “reclaiming Christianity from the religious right and putting faith into action for social justice.” One of Faithful America’s campaigns is called “Don’t put pastors on trial for performing gay weddings.”

Johnson was asked to receive the petitions, according to John Coleman, communications director for the Eastern Pennsylvania Annual (regional) Conference, who supplied the information about the presentation.

“Bishop Peggy Johnson, please join with the growing number of United Methodists who are obeying Jesus’ command to love our neighbors and disregarding the church’s immoral anti-gay rules. Don’t allow any more trials for pastors who officiate at gay weddings,” the petition read.

Johnson, episcopal leader for the Eastern Pennsylvania Area where the trial took place, told the more than 30 gathered in the parking lot outside of the conference office that she did all she could to avoid a church trial but her efforts failed, Coleman said.

Ruth Ann “Bunnie” Bryant, a member of Union United Methodist Church in Havertown, Pa., and the Rev. Karen Wiseman, professor at Lancaster (Penn.) Seminary, presented the petition to Johnson. Richard Kirk, conference co-chair of Reconciling Ministries Network, an unofficial caucus of The United Methodist Church, also spoke.

Schaefer was given a 30-day suspension by the jury in his church trial and told that if he can’t uphold the Book of Discipline in its entirety he must surrender his credentials.

Schaefer was found guilty of violating the church’s law against pastors performing same-sex unions and of disobedience to the order and discipline of The United Methodist Church. He acknowledged having performed the same-sex wedding of his son, Tim, in 2007.

The 30 day-suspension will cover both convictions, the jury said. Schaefer also is to be monitored by his district superintendent and must meet with the conference’s Board of Ordained Ministry during the suspension period.

Three other United Methodist elders are facing complaints — all in the state of New York.

A complaint was filed against the Rev. Stephen Heiss, pastor of Tabernacle United Methodist Church, Binghamton, N.Y., for officiating at his daughter’s same-sex union.

In a letter to Bishop Mark J. Webb, episcopal leader of the Upper New York Conference, Heiss said he has officiated at several other same-sex unions and plans to officiate at another wedding for two women.

Heiss has been receiving letters of support on a blog, letters to the bishop, started in early September. As of Sept. 23, 85 letters have been written, several from members of Tabernacle United Methodist Church.

A statement was issued from the episcopal office in July, and Heiss and Webb met to discuss the issue in August. A second meeting took place Sept. 20 and Webb extended the process for another 30 days.

In October 2012, the Rev. Thomas Ogletree, a retired seminary dean and elder, officiated at the same-sex wedding of his son. Some clergy in the New York Annual (regional) Conference filed a complaint against Ogletree after his son’s wedding announcement appeared in the New York Times.

The Rev. Sara Thompson Tweedy is also facing a formal complaint in the New York Conference that she is a “self-avowed practicing” lesbian.

* Gilbert is a multimedia reporter for the young adult content team at United Methodist Communications, Nashville, Tenn. Contact her at (615) 742-5470 


Like what you're reading?  United Methodist Communications is celebrating 80 years of ministry! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community.  Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

umnews-subscriptions
Racism
The Rev. David Maldonado. Video image courtesy of IMU Latina (Iglesia Metodista Unida Latina) via YouTube by UM News.

Church must hear Hispanic/Latino voices

The lack of voices from Latin America represents a major gap in the global conversations occurring in The United Methodist Church.
General Church
An offering plate is passed down the pew at Cathedral of the Rockies, a United Methodist church in Boise, Idaho. The General Council on Finance and Administration board surveyed U.S. conference treasurers to find out what impact potential church disaffiliations and church closures will have on the apportionment formula over the next four years. 2018 file photo by Mary Kienzle, United Methodist Communications.

Estimating financial impact of church exits

United Methodist financial leaders voted on agencies’ 2021 budgets at the same time they looked at the costs of a potential church split and a proposal to reduce bishops.
Social Concerns
United Methodist Bishop LaTrelle Easterling speaks at the virtual Inclusiveness Conference, organized by the United Methodist Association of Retired Clergy. The leader of the Baltimore-Washington Conference called on United Methodists not to back down from their commitment to dismantle racism. Photo by the Rev. Valerie L. Jackson, one of the event’s moderators.

Planning for a more inclusive church

A United Methodist conference focused on church efforts to dismantle racism, welcome LGBTQ people and cross international boundaries.