Mixed blessings in new U.S. church numbers

Melissa Crutchfield of the United Methodist Committee on Relief helps distribute water-treatment supplies to people living in a makeshift camp in Gresier, Haiti, in January 2010. UMNS file photos by Mike DuBose.
Melissa Crutchfield of the United Methodist Committee on Relief helps distribute water-treatment supplies to people living in a makeshift camp in Gresier, Haiti, in January 2010. UMNS file photos by Mike DuBose.

United Methodist churches in the United States are weathering a declining membership trend and a difficult economy, which have combined to cause local church spending to decline. But recently released statistics for 2010 and 2011 also show:

  • Giving in 2010 to the Advance, which includes contributions to the United Methodist Committee on Relief, increased a whopping 146 percent from 2009 to more than $44.9 million, in large part because of contributions for Haiti.
  • Direct giving to United Methodist-related causes increased by more than 29 percent.
  • Seventeen annual (regional) conferences paid 100 percent of their general apportioned funds for 2011, up from 15 conferences in 2010.
  • The United Methodist Church remains the third-largest religious group in the United States, and its membership trends - decreases in the United States and increases in other countries - mirror those of other mainline denominations.

The report from the General Council on Finance and Administration found membership in the United States now at 7,570,980. Membership worldwide totals about 12 million, with most of the church growth in Africa and the Philippines. Membership statistics from episcopal areas outside the United States will be available by mid-March.

Statistics as reported by local churches and annual conferences indicate that professing membership in 2010 was down 1.4 percent from 2009, and average worship attendance was down 2.3 percent. In 2009, membership decreased 1.2 percent and attendance, 1.9 percent.

In 2005, The United Methodist Church established two categories of membership baptized and professing. A total of 140,295 persons were received in United Methodist congregations on "profession of faith" or "faith restored" in 2010, a 1.4 percent decline from 2009.

The 2010 report indicates only 54 percent of churches reported receiving any members by profession of faith or faith restored, down from slightly more than 58 percent in 2005.

"That figure is not as stark as it appears," said Scott Brewer, staff executive for connectional services at the finance agency. "Some churches only conduct confirmation classes every other year. Twenty-one percent of churches haven't received anyone by profession of faith in the last three years."

Young volunteers from the Methodist Church in Haiti measure rice for humanitarian relief in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, in January 2010.
Young volunteers from the Methodist Church in Haiti measure rice for humanitarian relief in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, in January 2010.

Brewer noted that churches report 73,000 young people in a confirmation class, which means nearly half of those joining by profession of faith are adults.

Brewer noted membership losses have occurred every year since the 1968 formation of The United Methodist Church, but percentage losses have increased since 2000.


Local U.S. church spending declined from 2009 to 2010 by 0.92 percent. Local church capital expenditures declined nearly 8 percent, while spending for all other categories increased by 0.67 percent.

However, in spite of the difficult economy, United Methodists responded generously to the needs of earthquake victims in Haiti and to other disasters.

"In times of great need, such as the devastation caused by natural disasters, we have seen United Methodists respond with tremendous generosity," said Laura Chambers, senior researcher at the council on finance and administration.

17 conferences pay full apportionments

The 17 annual conferences that paid 100 percent of their general apportioned funds for 2011 are Alaska, Baltimore-Washington, Central Texas, Desert Southwest, East Ohio, Greater New Jersey, Holston, Illinois Great Rivers, Iowa, New York, North Carolina, Northern Illinois, Oklahoma Indian Missionary, Peninsula Delaware, Red Bird Missionary, West Virginia and Western Pennsylvania. In 2010, 15 conferences gave 100 percent to all seven general apportioned funds.

More data can be found on GCFA's website.

Additional information related to the statistics of the denomination will be reported in the Connectional Table's State of the Church Report later this year.

Membership Data

Apportionment Info

Holston was one of the conferences joining the 100-percent club by increasing its giving from 61 percent in 2010. "We have made a concentrated effort over the past several years to pay the general and jurisdictional apportionments which support connectional ministries at 100 percent," said John Tate, director of financial services for the Holston Conference. "We felt it was important to make the adjustments in budgeting and ministry as an example to the churches that we are asking to pay 100 percent as well."

Five annual conferences did not pay 100 percent of all apportionments but gave 100 percent to the World Service Fund, the largest apportioned fund, in 2011. Conferences that paid the full amount to the fund are Rio Grande, Texas, Upper New York, Western Michigan and Wisconsin. The World Service Fund supports the ministries of all general church program agencies.

While the complete report on 2011 will not be available for a few months, it is clear that the natural disasters in 2011 resulted in fewer dollars to UMCOR compared with 2010, but giving in 2011 is up 30 percent from the total given in 2009.

Small groups and community outreach

The number of Christian formation participants in local churches increased 4 percent from 2009, while reported participation in covenant discipleship groups increased nearly 11 percent, and enrollees in Vacation Bible School increased almost 6 percent.

U.S. churches reported serving more than 1.1 million people through daycare and education ministries, and nearly 26.3 million through ministries of outreach, justice and mercy.

*Peck is a retired clergy member of New York Annual Conference. Sharon Dean, communications director for the General Council on Finance and Administration, contributed to this story.

News media contact: Heather Hahn, Nashville, Tenn., (615) 742-5470 or newsdesk@umcom.org.

Sign up for our newsletter!

General Church
The U.S. Capitol is framed by trees across from the United Methodist Building in Washington, D.C. File photo by Kathleen Barry, UMNS.

38 United Methodists serve in 116th Congress

United Methodists comprise the fourth-largest religious group in a new Congress that has fewer Christians and slightly more religious diversity.
U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions had faced official church complaints from fellow United Methodists, but those were dismissed by a district superintendent in the Alabama-West Florida Conference. Photo courtesy U.S. Department of Justice.

Complaints against Sessions dismissed

Conference leaders conclude church law doesn’t apply to ‘political actions’ by the U.S. attorney general.
custom text here

Order ending family separations welcomed

Still, United Methodists cautioned that details of any policy shift are important and stressed that the executive order isn’t enough.