Massachusetts church says it’s open for same-sex weddings

The council of Harvard-Epworth United Methodist Church in Cambridge, Mass., has approved a “Marriage Equality Statement” saying that the church’s building is available for same-sex weddings and the congregation will support its pastor, the Rev. Scott Campbell, if he performs such services there.

The United Methodist Church officially holds that homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching. Church law also forbids United Methodist pastors from officiating at same-sex unions and says such services “shall not be conducted in our churches.”

John Regier, the church council member who drafted the statement, noted that Harvard-Epworth has long supported same-sex marriage and that Campbell has been a leader in trying to change church law regarding homosexuality.

“We finally got to the point that we were not prepared to wait for the (church) law to change, and we wanted to express who we are as a congregation,” Regier said. “Ultimately it’s up to the pastor to decide what religious services take place in a church. We wanted this pastor and any future pastor to know that we were supportive of same-sex marriage.”

The council’s unanimous vote came at a meeting Monday, Oct. 21. All church members were invited to attend and join in discussion before the vote.

Massachusetts has allowed same-sex marriage since 2004.

Campbell said there have been no same-sex weddings at Harvard-Epworth, and none is scheduled. But he said he is willing to conduct such weddings there.

Campbell said a copy of the statement, with an explanatory letter, is on its way to Bishop Sudarshana Devadhar of the New England (annual) Regional Conference.

Devadhar said, “I am aware of the letter and its content. At this time, it appears that the letter describes a future intent, and no specific event has been reported. When matters like this come to my desk they are addressed on a case-by-case basis, and as a temporal and spiritual leader of the church, I am committed to dealing with such matters theologically and pastorally.”

Campbell said he’s unaware of any sanction the congregation could face if the church building is used for a same-sex wedding.

“The obvious sanction would be that the bishop would have the right to remove a pastor from an appointment if an action that were deemed contrary to the polity of the church were to take place,” he said.

The Reconciling Ministries Network, an unofficial caucus in the United Methodist Church that seeks to change church law regarding homosexuality, said 16 United Methodist churches are on its “Altar for All” list.

Fourteen have pledged a willingness to have same-sex ceremonies in their buildings, and two have decided not to hold any weddings as a protest of state laws prohibiting same-sex weddings.

Sign up for our newsletter!

SUBSCRIBE

Latest News

General Church
The Rev. Timothy Bruster speaks with fellow delegates from Central Texas Conference during the special General Conference in February. Bruster made a motion, which was passed, to request a declaratory decision by the Judicial Council on “the constitutionality, meaning, application and effect” of the Traditional Plan. Photo courtesy of J. Vance Morton, Central Texas Conference.

Top court meets in aftermath of GC2019

In spring meeting, United Methodist Judicial Council to review Traditional Plan and disaffiliation legislation adopted by special General Conference.
Bishops
Manila Area Bishop Ciriaco Q. Francisco (left) presides at a meeting of the Standing Committee on Central Conference Matters in Manila, Philippines. At right is the Rev. Deanna Stickley-Miner, the committee’s secretary. Photo by Heather Hahn, UMNS.

Feedback sought on global Discipline effort

After the tumultuous GC2019, United Methodist leaders have delayed asking General Conference to vote on what is adaptable in the Book of Discipline.
General Church
A banner with a message of inclusion and a rainbow flag fly outside Saint Mark United Methodist Church in Atlanta. Resistance continues to passage of the Traditional Plan at last month’s special called General Conference in St. Louis. Photo courtesy of Saint Mark United Methodist Church.

Resistance to GC2019 spreads

United Methodists unhappy about passage of Traditional Plan find various ways to apologize to the LGBTQ community— and to protest.