Language on board membership is unconstitutional, Judicial Council says

Petitions that seek to guarantee membership of certain types of people to General Conference and to United Methodist general agencies are unconstitutional, the Judicial Council ruled.

Responding to a request for a decision from the floor of the opening plenary session of 2008 General Conference, the council cited previous rulings Decisions 594 and 601 in which the denomination's supreme court forbade "any legislation which would guarantee a preferred status not extended to others."

In Decision 1090, the Judicial Council cited its ruling in Decision 601 that disciplinary provisions that "recommend" or ask that "special attention" be given to membership of certain categories of persons on general boards are constitutional. The council cited Paragraph 705.3i of the 2004 Book of Discipline as an example.

Kevin Goodwin, delegate from the Peninsula-Delaware Annual (regional) Conference, asked for the ruling April 23. He cited six petitions that mandate agency membership for disabled persons, youth and central conference members, and that guaranteed representation of youth, young adults and central conference as delegates at General Conference.

The Judicial Council ruled that if any of the petitions were to be adopted, they would "guarantee a preferred status and are, therefore, unconstitutional."

Shamwange P. Kyungu was absent. C. Rex Bevins, the first clergy alternate, participated in this decision.

*Caldwell is editor of the Virginia United Methodist Advocate and covers the Judicial Council for United Methodist News Service.

News media contact: Kathy Noble or Tim Tanton, e-mail: newsdesk@umcom.org.

Phone calls can be made to the General Conference Newsroom in Fort Worth, Texas, at (817) 698-4405(817) 698-4405 until May 3. Afterward, call United Methodist News Service in Nashville, Tenn., at (615) 742-5470(615) 742-5470.

Related Articles

General Conference headlines

Request anticipates constitutionality questions

Resource

General Conference 2008

Judicial Council

You'll need Skype CreditFree via Skype

Sign up for our newsletter!

SUBSCRIBE

Latest News

General Conference
The Book of Discipline contains the rules that guide The United Methodist Church. Only General Conference can change the book, which is revised after each meeting of the conference. Photo by Mike DuBose, UMNS.

List of GC2019 petitions under court review

Downloadable PDF lists approved changes to the Book of Discipline that will be reviewed by the Judicial Council in April.
General Church
As the Rev. Joe Harris presides over the legislative committee, the results of a vote approving the Traditional Plan as amended by 461-359 are displayed. The vote must still be approved by the plenary session on Feb. 26, the final day of the special session of the 2019 General Conference of The United Methodist Church in St. Louis. Photo by Paul Jeffrey, UMNS.

Traditional Plan advances as One Church, Simple plans fail

General Conference 2019 delegates moved the Traditional Plan forward to plenary, not the One Church Plan or the Simple.
General Church
Delegate Norma Kehrberg uses an electronic voting machine during a Feb. 24 plenary session of the special General Conference of The United Methodist Church, held in St. Louis. Photo by Paul Jeffrey, UMNS.

Traditional and One Church backers gear up

The Traditional Plan is the top priority as delegates begin their second day of legislative committee. But One Church Plan backers have not given up.