Court rules on question of authority

Translate Page

In response to a request for review from General Conference 2016, the United Methodist Judicial Council has found no conflict between two of its previous decisions or between specific paragraphs in the church’s constitution.

Decision 1321, issued May 20, said that Paragraphs 16 and 33 of the constitution “assign specific authority and responsibility to the General Conference and to the annual conferences in The United Methodist Church. They are not in conflict.”

The Rev. Jeremy Troxler, Western North Carolina Conference, made the motion for the review during a May 16 plenary session. He said he believed there was “a basic separation of constitutional power issue here that Judicial Council must resolve” related to standards of ministry and ordination.

Paragraph 16 gives General Conference “full legislative power over all matters distinctly connectional,” the decision said, and Paragraph 16.2 gives General Conference the authority to “define and fix the powers and duties” of ordained, licensed and certified ministers.”

Paragraph 33 says the annual conference has the right to vote “on all matters relating to the character and conference relations of its clergy members and on the ordination of clergy.”

The council said it had addressed this concern “in multiple decisions through the years,” citing Decisions 7, 536 and 823.

The two previous decisions the council was asked to review – Decisions 542 and 544 – also are not in conflict, Judicial Council ruled.

In Decision 544, the council ruled that the 1984 General Conference had the authority to add language to the Book of Discipline that “self-avowed practicing homosexuals are not to be certified as candidates, ordained as ministers or appointed to serve.”

In Decision 542, the council ruled that annual conferences “have the authority to decide whether candidates for ordination meet the disciplinary qualifications.”

“Seen in isolation from the longer history of the Judicial Council jurisprudence, these decisions may appear to be conflicting,” the decision said. “But seen in the full history of numerous Judicial Council decisions on these constitutional matters, it is clear that no conflict exists either within the constitution or between the two aforementioned decisions of the Judicial Council.”

Decision 1321 also cited two “legitimate legislative enactments of the General Conference” – Paragraphs 304 and 2702. Paragraph 304 gives annual conferences “responsibility…regarding admission to the ministry of the clergy” while Paragraph 2702 assigns annual conferences “responsibility for handling complaints and charges filed against clergy.”

The council pointed out that Paragraph 33 grants annual conferences “such other rights as have not been delegated to the General Conference under the constitution.” Legislative authority is delegated only to General Conference, the decision said.

“The annual conferences have clear authority under the constitution,” the decision said. “But that authority does not and constitutionally cannot intrude into the authority of the General Conference.”

Bloom is a United Methodist News Service multimedia reporter based in New York. Follow her at https://twitter.com/umcscribe or contact her at (615)742-5470 or [email protected]


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

UMNEWS-SUBSCRIPTION
General Church
With some congregations considering leaving The United Methodist Church or just wondering about its future, Ask The UMC offers a series of questions and answers to help clear up some common misperceptions or misinformation around disaffiliation. Graphic by Laurens Glass, United Methodist Communications.

Ask The UMC: Is The United Methodist Church really... ? (Part 5)

Do we have to choose between The UMC and the GMC? What happens if an elected delegate disaffiliates?
Judicial Council
Bishops process into worship at the 2019 special session of the General Conference held in St. Louis. Amid increasing church disaffiliations, bishops are speaking out to address misinformation they say is being spread about The United Methodist Church’s future. File photo by Paul Jeffrey, UM News.

Bishops push back against recruitment tactics

Bishops are trying to set the record straight on misinformation being spread about The United Methodist Church’s future. They also are working toward building a church where traditionalists, centrists and progressives will all feel they belong.
General Agencies
The General Council on Finance and Administration board at its online meeting Aug. 19 designated how to use proceeds from the sale of the agency’s headquarters in Nashville, Tennessee. The agency staff members are moving into the nearby Harry Denman Building, which is also home to Discipleship Ministries and the United Methodist Board of Higher Education and Ministry. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Grappling with mixed news on giving, church exits

Board members of The United Methodist Church’s finance agency discussed the potential impact of rising church disaffiliations even as they celebrated an uptick in giving and the sale of the agency’s building.