Churches beware: Liability insurance a must

Editor's note:This is part of a continuing series on what churches can do to protect from the unanticipated. Earlier parts of the series focused on Church fires: Damage, recovery, prevention.

While a contractor can tell with some certainty the cost per square foot to rebuild a burned church building, a defense attorney cannot tell you with certainty what to expect in a serious liability lawsuit.

The worry of fire or natural disaster that destroys the property is easy for church stewards to recognize, but the concerns of potential liability actions charging physical or mental damage are not always as obvious until the unanticipated occurs.

General liability insurance is necessary for any business, with or without a storefront. That is true for churches as well.

Most general liability insurance policies for nonprofit organizations - which is where churches are categorized - protect the corporate entity, its subsidiaries and affiliates, its executive officers, employees and volunteers for their actions on behalf of the organization. These policies are designed to protect against civil liability for bodily injury, property damage or personal injury to others.

These are the assumptions in this kind of policy:

  • The claim in a lawsuit must seek compensation because of injury or damage.
  • The injury or damage must have been fortuitous and have occurred during the policy term.
  • The policyholder must be liable for the injury or damage.

There also are costs that most churches would not think about. For instance, a general liability policy also covers funds required to defend the insured policyholders, such as legal and expert-witness fees, reasonable costs to secure other witnesses for court appearance, post-judgment interest and appeal-bond premiums. These "supplementary payments" are normally payable in addition to the stated limit of liability. A conventional general liability policy has no deductible.

Premises, contracts, injuries and more

What to consider

Church leaders should purchase liability coverage only from companies that specialize in church risks. Some of these companies are United Methodist Insurance, Cincinnati Insurance, Church Mutual, Brotherhood Mutual and GuideOne. These carriers understand the intricacies of church claims and coverage issues.

After narrowing the field to church carriers, the congregation should determine minimum liability insurance requirements in terms of what constitutes acceptable coverage limits. United Methodist Insurance suggests the minimum liability insurance requirements as a guideline for congregations.

The ideal general liability policy provides a broad range of coverage for a variety of operational risks. That is why it is called a broad-form contract. This type of policy commonly includes:

  • Premises and operations liability, attributable to aspects of the physical plant or daily operations. Examples: A visitor trips on a cracked sidewalk (premises liability) or boisterous, unsupervised children knock down an older parishioner (operations liability).
  • Contractual liability for injury or damage assumed by oral or written contract. Example: The municipal parks and recreation department asks the church to defend and pay a bodily injury claim pursuant to signing a facilities-use agreement for a church picnic at a city park.
  • Personal injury liability for false arrest, detention or malicious prosecution; libel, slander or defamation; and invasion of an individual's right of privacy. Example: A community member sues after the church newsletter publishes controversial statements about her.
  • Advertising injury liability for plagiarism or piracy of one's copyright or trademark. Example: Another business claims the policyholder's logo is confusingly similar to its own.
  • Legal liability for fire damage to someone else's property while the policyholder is occupying it. Example: A cabin sustains fire damage originating from a smoldering cigarette during a retreat.
  • Incidental medical malpractice liability for a non-medical professional's rendering of, or failure to render, medical aid. Example: A pastor administers cardiopulmonary resuscitation with an adverse outcome.
  • Products liability for injury or damage caused by a "product" made or sold by the policyholder. Example: A child sustains an injury by a pre-owned toy purchased at a church rummage sale.
  • Medical payments liability for cost of medical treatment, payable without regard to or concession of policyholder's liability. Example: The church offers to cover emergency-room bills after a parishioner falls on icy steps.

Churches must be even more specific

Churches must expand a broad-form general liability policy to address significant church-related exposures:

  • Pastoral counseling liability risk is physical or emotional injury attributable to a clergyperson's acts, errors or omissions during counseling of a spiritual nature. Example: A couple alleges that marital counseling further injured their relationship.
  • Sexual misconduct liability risk is physical or emotional injury because of sexual abuse, molestation or exploitation. Example: A minister initiates a sexual relationship with a parishioner to whom he or she has provided pastoral guidance.
  • Cemetery operations (including columbaria) liability risk is physical or emotional injury because of an act or omission in connection with the cremation, burial, disinterment or temporary care of any deceased human body. Example: Cremains held for temporary safekeeping until burial are misplaced.
  • Teachers' liability risk is bodily injury or property damage arising out of teaching activities, including the administration of corporal punishment.

Some things not covered

Although the typical general liability policy contains a variety of situations not covered by the contract, here are some of the most noteworthy exclusions:

  • Liability arising in connection with ownership, maintenance, operation, use, loading or unloading of automobiles, aircraft and large watercraft.
  • Employment-related liabilities, including obligations under Workers' Compensation, unemployment or disability benefits laws and work-related claims under common law by employees or their family members.
  • Damage to property owned, used or occupied by the policyholder, or property in an insured's care, custody or control.
  • Liability resulting from the willful violation of laws addressing discrimination, humiliation, harassment or wrongful termination because of race, creed, age or sex.
  • Fines, penalties, punitive or exemplary damages typically awarded to punish willful, wanton or reckless behavior (gross negligence).
  • Liability arising from pollution, nuclear energy or asbestos.

Finding the right insurance is a challenge. As your guiding principle, remember the words once told me by a wise trustee:

"All insurance policies are the same until you have a claim."

*Stephens is vice president of marketing and risk-management services for The Church Insurance Agency Corporation, a service provider to United Methodist Insurance. United Methodist Insurance is a wholly owned, nonprofit subsidiary of the General Council on Finance and Administration of The United Methodist Church.


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

UMNEWS-SUBSCRIPTION
Mission and Ministry
Tim Tanton (center, in red), chief news and information officer for United Methodist Communications, shares updates with African communicators and other UMCom staff during the 2019 General Conference. World Press Freedom Day, observed May 3, commemorates journalists and highlights the difficulties they face while reporting truth. File photo by Kathleen Barry, UM News

World Press Freedom Day and the church

Tim Tanton with United Methodist News talks about giving voice to the voiceless and why freedom of information is essential not only for society but for the church.
Evangelism
The Rev. Tom Berlin (left) presents a copy of his book, “Courage,” to Massachusetts National Guard Chaplain Chad McCabe in the chapel at Wesley Theological Seminary in Washington. McCabe, whose unit was assigned to help provide security at the U.S. Capitol after the January riot, contacted Wesley Seminary asking for Bibles, novels and board games for troops stationed there. Photo by Lisa Helfert for Wesley Theological Seminary. Copyright 2021. All rights reserved. Used with permission.

Church responds to chaplain's call to help soldiers

A National Guard chaplain got Bibles, games and 150 copies of a new book about courage when he turned to Wesley Theological Seminary for help keeping soldiers occupied in Washington in the aftermath of the Capitol insurrection.
Violence
The Rev. William B. Lawrence.  Photo by H. Jackson/Southern Methodist University.

What would Jesus tell the US Capitol rioters?

The Rev. William B. Lawrence examines the claims of Scriptural authority by violent protesters who stormed the U.S. Capitol.