Carcaño speaks out for modern-day outcasts

United Methodist Bishop Minerva Carcaño of the church's Phoenix Area preaches during morning worship on April 27 at the 2008 General Conference. A UMNS photo by Paul Jeffrey.

United Methodist Bishop Minerva Carcaño of the church's Phoenix Area preaches during morning worship on April 27 at the 2008 General Conference. A UMNS photo by Paul Jeffrey.

The church must be empowered by a "hope beyond ourselves" if it is going to eliminate poverty, a United Methodist bishop told the denomination's top legislative body.

That hope comes only through faith in Jesus Christ, said Bishop Minerva Carcaño of the church's Phoenix Area during the April 27 worship service at General Conference. The United Methodist Church has declared ministry with the poor as one of its four areas of focus for the immediate future.

Using the Gospel story of the Gerasene demoniac named Legion, found in Mark 5:1-20, Carcaño drew parallels to many in today's world who are sentenced to dwell in a wasteland, as the Gerasene who lived in the community cemetery.

"Where I live," said the bishop of the Desert Southwest Annual (regional) Conference, "a desert swallows up men, women and children every year." Her conference encompasses Arizona and part of Nevada.

She called these immigrants — struggling to cross the desert from Mexico to the United States — modern-day Legions. Most people would consider them to be lost causes.

"Jesus is not an American, German, Filipino, Liberian or even Nazarene. Nor is Jesus beholden to U.S. immigration policies or the policies of any nation." — Bishop Minerva Carcaño

While recognizing that immigration is a polarizing issue in The United Methodist Church, Carcaño lifted up those working to alleviate immigrants' suffering, including those United Methodists who provide water to travelers in the vast Sonoran Desert. United Methodists volunteer with Humane Borders, a faith-based organization supported by the United Methodist Committee on Relief, which provides water tanks in the desert.

In appealing for a change in approach to immigration in the United States and abroad, Carcaño said, "Jesus is not an American, German, Filipino, Liberian or even Nazarene. Nor is Jesus beholden to U.S. immigration policies or the policies of any nation." Her statement was met by enthusiastic applause throughout the arena.

The roots of poverty

Carcaño widened the scope of those stranded in the Gerasene cemetery to the hundreds of thousands of refugees suffering a "legion of torments."

"Poverty affects too many of our brothers and sisters," she continued, pointing to the "economic machine" and cultural understandings that root people in poverty.

"I cannot preach from this pulpit made from a tree that fell in Hurricane Katrina without speaking of the needs of those affected," Carcaño proclaimed, noting that institutional racism left people vulnerable and racism slowed the response to the hurricane's devastation. The pulpit at the General Conference is made of wood from the grounds of the Gulfside Assembly, a United Methodist retreat at Waveland, Miss., much of which was destroyed by the 2005 hurricane.

Racism and classism are not limited to the United States but are factors in global poverty, the bishop continued. "As United Methodists, we have committed to overcome poverty in community with the poor," she said. "I'm not so sure." Is this a reachable goal? "I do not lose hope."

Paralyzed by fear

Her reservation about the focus on poverty concerns fear. She said there is fear of the enormity of the task, of being overwhelmed, of losing identity as a church and of "the Legions of the world."

"Grow up," the preacher said in response to these fears. "Let us grow up and quit hiding behind fear."

Carcaño said the church needs to confess that it may be complicit in poverty, that many U.S. members may have more than they deserve and are not faithful in using their resources wisely. Faith and confession, she said, will lead to freedom from fear.

With the song "The Whole World in God's Hands" playing in the background, worship closed with a slideshow of people considered the Legions of today-people stuck in grinding poverty and those who are ministering to them.

*Scott is the communications director of the United Methodist Committee on Relief.

News media contact: Marta Aldrich, e-mail: [email protected].

Phone calls can be made to the General Conference Newsroom in Fort Worth, Texas, at (817) 698-4405 until May 3. Afterward, call United Methodist News Service in Nashville, Tenn., at (615) 742-5470.

Related Articles

General Conference headlines

Church urges humane treatment of immigrants


General Conference 2008

Welcoming the Migrant to the U.S. 

United States-Mexico Border

Sermon Text: A Hope beyond Ourselves

Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at

Sign up for our newsletter!

The Virginia Conference’s Bishop Sharma D. Lewis (upper right corner) leads the devotional during the April 30 session of the United Methodist Council of Bishops spring meeting. The bishops maintained that no elections of bishops or agency board members would be held this year, despite some delegates urging otherwise. Screengrab courtesy of the Council of Bishops via ZOOM by UM News.

Bishops: No episcopal elections until 2022

United Methodist bishops declined General Conference delegates’ calls for episcopal elections this year but opened the door to a vote on new leaders in 2022.
Local Church
Juan Martinez shows off his renewed Mexican passport outside Kingwood United Methodist Church in northeast Houston. The church provided office space and volunteers as a team from the Mexican Consulate in Houston worked to issue and update official documents for Mexicans living in the Houston area and beyond. Photo by Sam Hodges, UM News.

Church partners with Mexican Consulate

Kingwood United Methodist of Houston provides space, volunteers for push to help Mexican citizens in the U.S. get Mexican passports and other documents.
General Church
Delegates from the Philippines and Southeast Asia sing during the 2019 United Methodist General Conference in St. Louis. Nearly 300 Filipino United Methodists joined a virtual conversation March 16 to talk about the Christmas Covenant and other plans for the future of The United Methodist Church. More webinars are planned for church members in Africa and Europe. File photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Restructuring legislation gets a hearing

The drafters of the Christmas Covenant are leading webinars in the Philippines, Africa and Europe about their proposal for changing the denomination’s global structure.