Appeal hearing set this week in Schaefer case

A United Methodist regional appeals committee will convene on June 20 to hear an appeal from Frank Schaefer on the loss of his ministerial credentials as the result of a church trial held Nov. 18-19, 2013.

The hearing of the Committee on Appeals of the Northeastern Jurisdiction of The United Methodist Church will begin at 10:30 a.m. ET at the Baltimore-Washington Airport Marriott. Schaefer, the former pastor of Zion United Methodist Church, Iona, Pa., was found guilty of violating church law by conducting a same-sex marriage ceremony for his son.

Jen Ihlo, president of the Northeastern Jurisdiction Committee on Appeals and a member of the Baltimore-Washington Annual (regional) Conference, said the committee would work in accordance with the United Methodist Book of Discipline.

Under church law (United Methodist Book of Discipline Par. 2715), the appeals committee can consider only two questions:

  1. Does the weight of evidence sustain the charges?
  2. Were there errors of church law “as to vitiate the verdict and/or the penalty?”

The committee includes four ordained clergy, one diaconal minister, one full-time local pastor and three lay people. Members of Schaefer’s episcopal area, which encompasses the Eastern Pennsylvania and Peninsula-Delaware annual (regional) conferences, must recue themselves from the case.

No witnesses will be heard during the appeal. The committee may consider the records of the trial and the arguments of counsel. By a majority vote, the committee may sustain the findings, reverse the penalty in whole or in part or remand the case to a new trial.

Background of case

A trial jury of ordained clergy from the Eastern Pennsylvania Annual (regional) Conference found Schaefer guilty of violating the denomination’s law book and of disobedience to the order and discipline of The United Methodist Church.

In the penalty stage of the trial, the court suspended Schaefer from his ministerial duties for 30 days and declared that if he could not “uphold the Discipline in its entirety” at the end of the suspension, he would surrender his credentials.

On Dec. 19, 2013, Schaefer met with the Eastern Pennsylvania Conference Board of Ordained Ministry and told them he could not agree to uphold the Discipline’s ban against performing same-sex marriages.

Schaefer and his legal counsel, the Rev. Robert E. Coombe, filed an appeal after the board of ordained ministry “deemed his ministerial credential surrendered.”

The appeal stated that “the penalty assessed by the trial court was in violation of Church law, which prohibits trial courts from conditioning reinstatement of a suspended elder on his proof of good conduct and from imposing a penalty based on what a pastor may intend to do in the future.”

The appeal cites Judicial Council decisions 240, 725, 915 and 950 as well as paragraphs 2701, 2715 and 2716 “and other provisions” in the United Methodist Book of Discipline.

The Book of Discipline since 1972 has stated that all people are of sacred worth but “the practice of homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching.”

Church law says that marriage is to be between a man and a woman and bans United Methodist clergy from performing and churches from hosting “ceremonies that celebrate homosexual unions.”

Sign up for our newsletter!

umnews-subscriptions
Local Church
Asbury Memorial Church in Savannah, Ga., is leaving The United Methodist Church in support of LGBTQ inclusion. The church, with more than 300 members, is the first since 2016 to leave expressly in opposition to the denomination’s bans on same-sex weddings and “self-avowed practicing” gay clergy. Photo courtesy of Asbury Memorial Church.

Church exits denomination for LGBTQ equality

The United Methodist Church has seen multiple disaffiliations lately, but a Georgia church is the first in recent years to leave expressly in support of its LGBTQ members.
Local Church
A view of the Granger, Ind., campus of Granger Community Church, which has left The United Methodist Church. It has been one of the denomination’s largest and best-attended churches, but leaders wanted to control who would be the next pastor. Photo courtesy of Granger Community Church.

Indiana megachurch leaves denomination

Granger Community Church, wanting to choose its own pastor, agrees to pay about $2.6 million to Indiana Conference.
Local Church
Yavapai County Superior Court upheld the claim of the Desert Southwest Conference to keep property used by Camp Verde Community Church. The Camp Verde congregation departed The United Methodist Church in 2017. Photo courtesy of Find-A-Church, United Methodist Communications.

Desert Southwest's claim to property upheld

A judge’s order compelled the relocation of a congregation that withdrew from The United Methodist Church.