Support UM News on World Press Freedom Day: Give to help sustain and expand the storytelling capacity of UM News. Your donation today will transform information into inspiration and ensure we can continue sharing stories of God’s work in the world through The UMC. Help us reach our $10,000 goal and keep this vital ministry fair, faithful, trusted and free for all!

Appeal for ‘set-aside’ bishop advances in legislative committee

The Superintendency Legislative Committee spent the majority of Friday morning debating the Council of Bishops’ request for a full time president before advancing the legislation with almost no changes.

If approved by the General Conference, Petition 20314 would add two new sentences to constitutional Paragraph 49, allowing the council to elect a fulltime president who would be relieved of residential responsibilities. Because it is a constitutional change, it would have to be ratified by two-thirds of the annual conferences.

The petition was approved in committee by a vote of 49 to 6, with 5 abstentions.

“I’ve gone back and forth, back and forth on this issue,” said the Rev. Debbie Wallace Padgett from Kentucky, “but as a global church, it’s important that the Council of Bishops president have the space to lead in a global way. That would be very important to central conferences. I am also thinking about the health of this person. We’re currently placing unhealthy expectations on that bishop in this time of thinking of better health and wellness throughout the church.”

Delegates heard from three bishops — Larry Goodpaster, Ann Sherer-Simpson and Bruce Oden — late Thursday on the rationale for the petition, and asked to see a copy of the proposed job description for the position, which had to be translated into multiple languages. The Rev. Jerry Kulah from Liberia held up that job description and said, “When I look at what I have here, it is nothing short of a CEO!”

The committee spent the majority of its time on an amendment by the Rev. Tommy Williams of the Texas Conference that would have required the Council of Bishops to nominate three active bishops and that the General Conference (starting in 2016) would select one president from that group.

“That would give more people a voice in the selection, especially the laity” Williams explained. “Bishops make the nominees, while the General Conference retains its historical position as the decision-making body.”

“That’s taking the request for set-aside bishop in a totally different direction,” countered the Rev. Sally Langford from Western North Carolina. “The need is for a fulltime president because the council already has a part-time leader. It becomes more ‘pope-like’ if you have the General Conference voting, because that person becomes accountable to the whole General Conference and would have more authority that the council president already has.”

In the end, the amendment from Williams was voted down by a wide margin.

Committee members also rejected an amendment to the amendment from Williams that would have required the council presidency to be rotated among the four global continents where the denomination is represented.


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at ResourceUMC.org/GiveUMCom.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Social Concerns
Bishop Julius C. Trimble. Photo by Tessa Tillett for the Indiana Conference.

Love demands compassionate response, prophetic witness

United Methodists have a long history of advocating for the needs of others. Today, that call continues.
Theology and Education
Cliff White. Photo courtesy of the author.

Why our church is in trouble

United Methodist leaders should stop pursuing ideological goals and instead focus on making disciples of Jesus Christ, says a longtime church member.
Church Leadership
Anna Riddle. Photo by Heather Gaydeski Photography.

Carrie Parrish's legacy holds lessons for today

A trailblazer for women clergy in The United Methodist Church, Parrish championed equality and fought to tear down barriers in her day.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2025 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved